A/HRC/32/21
conducted at the regional level provide some understanding of the success of regulatory
measures designed to restrict the proliferation of private ownership of firearms and their
impact on the reduction in firearms-related death and violence.56 In several European
countries, research has suggested that low firearm homicide rates point to a certain level of
association between firearm ownership and firearm homicide. 57 In the Americas, the InterAmerican Commission on Human Rights noted in its report that “the most successful
experiences in crime prevention in the Hemisphere have focused mainly on dealing with the
factors that make violence a recurring problem at the local level. These efforts have
involved measures to … regulate private possession of firearms.”58 It should be noted,
however, that other factors may need to be taken into account, including the adoption
alongside specific firearm legislation of a range of other measures in the field of criminal
law, education and social programmes.
46.
In the framework of the present report, some States have provided a self-evaluation
of their respective domestic firearms regulations and how they contribute to the protection
of human rights. The majority of those States that responded on those questions indicated
that the regulation of civilian access to firearms had led to a reduction in homicides caused
by firearms59 and better protected the rights to life and security60 and physical integrity of
the person.61 Furthermore, many States concurred in their responses that the very
establishment of a legal framework to control the possession of firearms has helped prevent
firearm-related violations.
47.
Among the States providing specific examples of self-evaluation, the United
Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland indicated that owing to the strict firearms
regulations in the country, only 29 fatalities had resulted from offences involving firearms
in the period 2013-2014. Australia noted that a there had been an ongoing, gradual decrease
in the misuse of firearms and that research had found that a government firearms-buyback
programme had cut suicides with the use of a firearm by 74 per cent. Honduras noted that
the regulations it had adopted between 2000 and 2013 to control firearms had shown
positive results. In Jamaica, national legislation had provided a critical framework for the
establishment and implementation of standards and a framework to regulate the possession,
use, transfer and disposal of civilian firearms.
48.
The effectiveness of firearms control also depends on the enforcement mechanism in
place. Thus, in the view of Madagascar, the effectiveness and impact of national regulation
depends on the dissemination of public information on the content of the firearms
56
57
58
59
60
61
14
European Commission, Evaluation of the Firearms Directive, final report, 2014 and N. Duquet and
M. Van Alstein, Firearms and Violent Deaths in Europe (Brussels, Flemish Peace Institute, 2015).
For studies at the national level, see N. Duquet and M. Van Alstein, Gun Control in Belgium:
A Review of Effects of the 2006 Weapons Law (Brussels, Flemish Peace Institute, 2015); Government
of Canada, “Firearms, accidental deaths, suicides and violent crime: an updated review of the
literature with special reference to the Canadian situation”; working document, September 1998,
chap. 8, available from www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/csj-sjc/jsp-sjp/wd98_4-dt98_4/p8.html; People’s
Assembly (South Africa), Infographic: evaluating the impact of firearm regulation on gun-homicides,
2014, available from www.pa.org.za/blog/infographic-evaluating-impact-firearm-regulation-g;
D. Cerqueira and J. M. P. de Mello, Pontifical Catholic University of Rio de Janeiro (Brazil),
Department of Economics, “Evaluating a national anti-firearm law and estimating the causal effect of
guns on crime”, available from www.econ.puc-rio.br/pdf/td607.pdf.
UNODC, Global Study, p. 69.
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Report on Citizen Security.
Belgium, Burundi and Mauritius.
Ecuador and Burundi.
Burkina Faso.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents