A/HRC/10/21
page 5
2. Opinions of the Working Group
7.
Pursuant to its methods of work,1 the Working Group, in addressing its Opinions to
Governments, drew their attention to former Commission on Human Rights resolutions 1997/50
and 2003/31 and Human Rights Council resolution 6/4, requesting them to take account of the
Working Group’s Opinions and, where necessary, to take appropriate steps to remedy the
situation of persons arbitrarily deprived of their liberty and to inform the Working Group of the
steps they had taken. On the expiry of the three-week deadline, the Opinions were transmitted to
the source.
Table 1
Opinions adopted during the fifty-first, fifty-second and
fifty-third sessions of the Working Group
Opinion
No.
1/2008
Government’s
reply
Syrian Arab
Republic
Equatorial
Guinea
Yes
United Arab
Emirates
Islamic Republic
of Iran
Syrian Arab
Republic
Yes
6/2008
Saudi Arabia
Yes
7/2008
Myanmar
Yes
8/2008
Colombia
Yes
9/2008
Yemen
Yes
2/2008
3/2008
4/2008
5/2008
1
Country
E/CN.4/1998/44, annex I.
No
Yes
Yes
Person(s) concerned
Mr. Mus’ab al-Hariri.
Opinion
Detention arbitrary,
category III.
Commandant Juan Ondo Abaga; Detention arbitrary,
Lieutenant-Colonel Florencio Elá categories I (between
Bibang, Pedro Esono Ntunu and 3 July 2005 and
Antimo Edu Nchama.
6 September 2005) and III
(since 3 July 2005).
Mr. Abdullah Sultan Sabihat
Detention arbitrary,
Ali Alili.
categories II and III.
Ms. Shamila (Delara)
Detention arbitrary,
Darabi Haghighi.
category III.
Detention arbitrary,
Messrs. Anwar al-Bunni;
categories II and III.
Michel Kilo and
Mahmoud ‘Issa.
Mr. Abdul Rahman b. Abdelaziz Detention arbitrary,
al Sudays.
category III.
Messrs. Ko Than Htun and
Detention arbitrary,
Ko Tin Htay.
category II.
Messrs. Frank Yair Estrada
Cases filed (paragraph 17 (a)
Marin; Carlos Andrés Giraldo
of the Working Group’s
Hincapié and Alejandro de Jesús methods of work) and
González Duque.
considering that their
detention was arbitrary.
Messrs. Frank Yair Estrada
Marin and Carlos Andrés
Giraldo Hincapié: detention
was arbitrary, to category I.
Mr. Saqar Abdelkader
Detention arbitrary,
al Chouitier.
categories I and II.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents