A/HRC/18/53
Government criticized the role of the media in distorting the facts, and claimed that the
reference to a “repressive minority” in the report was unacceptable. It also claimed that this
particular reference demonstrated the biased approach of the mission. According to the note
verbale, the reference to 1,900 people killed in the country was correct. However, it added
that the figure included police and security officers, as well as victims of terrorist armed
groups. The Government also explained that 120 police officers had been brutally killed in
Jisr-el Shoughour by armed groups.
III. Patterns of violations
69.
The mission found a pattern of human rights violations constituting widespread or
systematic attacks against the civilian population, which may amount to crimes against
humanity, as provided for in article 7 of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal
Court.
A.
Murder and disappearances
70.
Following the widespread killing of civilians by Government-controlled security
forces, the Syrian Arab Republic has grossly violated the non-derogable right to life,
enshrined in article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.
71.
The mission gathered corroborative eyewitness statements on numerous summary
executions, including 353 named victims. In addition, the mission found corroborative
accounts indicating that members of the security forces posed as civilians in order to cause
unrest and to depict an inaccurate view of events. Civilians were often able to distinguish
themselves from members of the security forces, who wore colour-coded armbands.64
Several types of security forces and the army were deployed to the demonstrations, but
were clearly not trained in crowd control.
72.
While violent incidents have been caused by a minority of civilians in some
demonstrations,65 the disproportionate use of force by military and security forces are a
violation of the State’s international human rights obligations.
73.
Reports from a wide variety of sources assert that the demonstrations were mostly
peaceful. Civilians of all ages participated in protests and often carried olive branches or
bared their chests to show that they were unarmed. Government-controlled media channels
reported these events inaccurately, in most cases attributing disturbances to “terrorist”
elements.66 Most killings reported were due to live ammunition fired by security forces, the
military and Shabbiha members using Kalashnikovs and other guns.67 Reports from
witnesses indicate that there was a widespread modus operandi to kill civilians by using (a)
forces on the ground; (b) snipers on rooftops; and (c) air power.
64
65
66
67
20
According to some reports, various security units would even at times shoot at each other.
For example, the mission received uncorroborated accounts from Baniyas and Jisr Al Shughour of the
killing of security or other officials by demonstrators or unidentified persons.
For example, there are corroborated reports that security forces planted weapons in the Omari
Mosque in the city of Dar’a after clearing it and murdering civilians, then blamed innocent
demonstrators. For the version of the Syrian Arab News Agency (DARA), see
www.sana.sy/eng/337/2011/04/27/343519.htm.
In several incidents documented by the mission, Shabbiha members used knives or bayonets to kill
protestors.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents