A/HRC/23/20
and the follow-up to their recommendations. Special procedures should not be used only as
an early warning mechanism, but also be seen as capable of following up and ensuring the
monitoring of implementation.
49.
Looking back on the historical development of the international human rights
system, a major weakness remained: that, in the drafting of the Charter, Chapter VII had
not been endowed with the possibility of imposing sanctions for human rights violations,
which would have allowed for greater protection. How cooperation could lead to the
normative development necessary to address emerging challenges was illustrated by the
examples of the work of the Advisory Committee on the rights of peasants and on children
affected by noma. On the former, cooperation with Vía Campesina, a non-governmental
organization networking with farmers, had laid the groundwork for the development of the
study prepared by the Committee and a draft declaration, which was now being examined
by an intergovernmental working group of the Human Rights Council and would allow
peasants to address the issue of land seizure. In the second example, non-governmental
organizations had raised the issue of children affected by noma and the relationship
between severe malnutrition and childhood diseases, which had led to the preparation of the
study and a set of guidelines by the Committee that had been adopted by the Council. As a
follow-up to that study, an initiative had been taken to bring the case to the World Health
Assembly, which would lead to the official recognition of noma as a disease and allow for
work to start on its monitoring and prevention. The issue was also being taken up by the
Committee on the Rights of the Child. These examples demonstrated the synergies that can
result from international cooperation and the use of existing mechanisms to advance issues.
50.
The universal periodic review process had opened broad perspectives for
international cooperation, building bridges between special procedures, treaty bodies, the
United Nations, non-governmental organizations and human rights defenders, and had
facilitated dialogue between different stakeholders in the field of human rights by the
sharing of best practices between and recommendations made by States. It had opened
doors to a dialogue where the North spoke on economic, social and cultural rights, and the
South on political and civil rights. Despite these advances, the universal periodic review
mechanism still faced obstacles, including the large number of recommendations made (on
average 150 for each State reviewed) and the lack of financial means to implement them
and to provide States with the technical assistance necessary. The rejection of
recommendations by States and non-cooperation were other challenges that had to be
addressed.
III. Conclusions
51.
Experts and speakers from the floor stated that the seminar had brought to
light the legal, political and moral dimensions of international cooperation, which was
multidimensional, and not directed by hierarchical relationships. A number of
positive elements had emerged from the constructive study prepared by the Advisory
Committee, but new additional channels needed to be explored, based on the
principles of the Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action. To date, the focus had
been predominantly on North-South cooperation; in the continued discussions on this
issue, however, more attention should also be paid to South-South cooperation. In
addition, the concept of non-cooperation should be defined and framed.
52.
Participants reaffirmed the importance of the universal periodic review process
as a new, innovative tool of the Human Rights Council. The first review cycle had
brought to light that cooperation should not be seen only as something vertical
(North-South), and that all States had gaps in their human rights performance that
international cooperation could help to overcome. Follow-up on implementation of
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents