A/HRC/22/29
citizen participation, poor or absent public debate, lack of effective empowerment policies
and access to justice, and unconstitutional access to power or change of government.
A.
Political and security challenges
29.
Weak or dysfunctional institutions are among the most serious challenges to
democracy. As highlighted above, democracy does not need to follow a uniform pattern. It
requires political commitment based on respect for human rights and institutional
compliance with the principles of the rule of law. Such interaction and cooperation can be
disrupted if all contending forces do not agree to work hand in hand.
30.
Continuously weakened institutions can collapse, leading to the breakdown of State
order. Among the primary generators of disruption are: an autocratic executive, an
inefficient or non-accountable Parliament, attempts to manipulate the constitutional order
and the outcome of elections, a military subservient to political interest instead of national
security, and the corrosive effects of corruption. The vacuum of authority is another serious
challenge for democracy and democratization.
31.
Unremitting societal engagement is indispensable to fend off disruption and reversal
of democracy. It also allows the community to keep at bay ―dictatorship nostalgia‖ and
temptations to step beyond the rule of law (lynching, vigilante groups). Ultimately, there
exists an ―ever-present connection between the security of persons and democratic
coexistence‖.8
32.
Globalization can also constitute a threat to democracy if States’ ability to control
the management of their resources, environment and economics is constantly challenged.
Similarly, the transnational nature of some prevailing security challenges, such as armed
groups operating across several countries, increases the threat on States’ political stability.
In recent years, this element has taken on a new dimension relating to the increase of
transnational terrorism whereby armed groups moving across boundaries represent serious
challenges for national, regional and global security. States’ responses to such threats must
be calibrated to avoid a further weakening of democracy. The post-September 11 era
witnessed several examples of infringements of human rights and erosions of the rule of
law in the context of countering terrorism. In this respect, it is particularly important to
stress that human rights may be limited only by law and to such an extent necessary to meet
the purpose for which the limitation is allowed in an open and democratic society.
33.
Violence is a major challenge to democracy. The responsibility of States to prevent
or contain violence is paramount before, during and after a political transition. In
addressing violence, they should tackle its proximate and deeper causalities as well as its
local, national and international dimensions. The institutionalization of strategic peace
processes in conflict and post-conflict societies has a significant effect on both the
prevention and management of violence in order to protect human rights under the rule of
law.
34.
Violence can also erupt when the introduction of democracy challenges the
foundations of a pre-existing undemocratic political order. Transitions to democracy are
inherently disorderly and multifaceted. Specifically, during transitions, members of the
former State apparatus may attempt to regain power. Within this context, the peaceful
8
8
Organization of American States, Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, ―Report on citizen
security and human rights‖, document OEA/Ser.L/V/II. (Doc. 57), para. 20. Available from
www.cidh.org/pdf%20files/SEGURIDAD%20CIUDADANA%202009%20ENG.pdf.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents