A/HRC/21/34
B.
Administration of justice and rule of law
22.
One legacy of years of armed conflict and underdevelopment in South Sudan is a
justice system that is weak, ineffective and inadequate. The shortage of professional police
and qualified judges and lawyers across much of South Sudan, as well as lack of basic
training, infrastructure, transport and equipment, severely affects the administration of
justice. The scope of territorial coverage and jurisdiction of the formal justice system is
narrow, and access to justice remains severely limited. The capacity of many institutions of
Government to uphold the rule of law and to promote and protect human rights is weak.
The traditional justice system, which covers more than 80 per cent of the country, mainly
relies on customary and traditional practices that very often violate statutory provisions and
international human rights standards. These chronic shortfalls adversely affect the delivery
of justice, including due process rights and legal representation.
23.
The death penalty remains in force in South Sudan; in 2011, at least six prisoners
were executed even though they had not been legally represented by counsel. Access to
legal aid is limited, and lawyers are not only expensive to retain, but too few in most areas.
Weak prosecutorial capacity and an insufficient number of judges continue to result in
widespread violations of human rights in the administration of justice, including perennial
trial delays, excessive remands, prolonged pretrial detention and overcrowded prisons.
24.
Largely as a result of an inadequately trained police force, arbitrary arrest and
detention are widespread in South Sudan and commonly combined with other serious
human rights violations, such as torture or other ill treatment of detainees and prolonged
detention. Many people have been detained as a result of flawed arrests and prosecutions,
or without any solid legal justification. A variety of State actors, including the police,
military and security personnel, bear responsibility for these abuses. Interference by
military and political figures in the justice system sometimes leads to arbitrary arrest and
detention, as the police often act on instruction or under threat rather than in accordance
with the law. Arrest and detention of family members in lieu of suspects remains a common
practice, as is protective custody, imprisonment for non-payment of debts and prolonged
pretrial detention. Children are sometimes tried and detained with adults, and are not
offered rehabilitation programmes or sufficient educational opportunities in prison. In the
absence of any psychiatric institutions in the country, people who show signs of mental
instability are often sent to prison. Meanwhile, detention conditions across the country
remain very poor, characterized by severely overcrowded and unhygienic cells and
dilapidated infrastructures.
25.
Impunity remains widespread in South Sudan, particularly among members of the
security forces. SPLA members often refuse to submit to civilian authority. Human rights
abuses are often not investigated and perpetrators are rarely identified and brought to
justice. State security agents enjoy what often seems to be complete impunity for human
rights violations, including arbitrary arrest and detention, ill treatment of detainees, sexual
and gender-based violence, and violations of the right to life.
26.
Of grave concern is the almost total lack of capacity to investigate and prosecute
serious crimes committed in the context of inter-communal violence. Despite having
established an investigation committee in the aftermath of the violence in Jonglei, the
Government has yet to demonstrate that it is serious about holding accountable those
responsible for such violence. Similarly, in March 2011, following a United Nations-led
investigation, a committee was formed by the Government to investigate allegations of
torture, rape and death of trainees at a police training academy outside Juba. The committee
presented its findings and recommendations to the Government. To date, no further action
has been taken to hold the perpetrators accountable.
7
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents