A/HRC/14/37
288. The International Federation of Human Rights Leagues and its affiliated league in
Italy, the Union of Jurists for the Protection of Human Rights, expressed satisfaction at the
large number of pertinent recommendations that had been made. It noted a marked increase
in racism and discriminatory behaviour against migrants and Roma and Sinti populations in
Italy. Despite existing legal instruments, judicial authorities had failed to prosecute those
responsible. It also stated that Italy’s reply in relation to questions on the treatment and
refoulement of illegal migrants and asylum seekers did not reflect the widespread practice
of pushing back migrants in the high seas. It further observed the increasing restrictions on
the freedom of expression and the right to information, and indicated that concerns raised
about media concentration were particularly relevant.
289. Amnesty International noted that many delegations had asked Italy to take effective
measures to counter racism and prevent discrimination against migrants, asylum seekers
and members of minorities. It welcomed Italy’s support for most recommendations on these
issues. It also noted with appreciation that Italy had accepted recommendations to ensure
compliance with international law in relation to forced evictions. It expressed
disappointment at the rejection of the recommendations to incorporate into domestic law
the crime of torture, as defined in the Convention against Torture, and urged Italy to
reconsider. Lastly, it regretted that Italy had rejected recommendations made to eliminate
from its legislation provisions that criminalized irregular entry and stay in the country, and
called on Italy to amend or withdraw these provisions.
290. The International Save the Children Alliance noted that Italy had not accepted a
recommendation relating to the prohibition of corporal punishment. It urged Italy to
prohibit corporal punishment and other forms of cruel or degrading punishment in all
settings, including the family, by enshrining the prohibition in national law. On the other
hand, the Alliance welcomed Italy’s acceptance of a recommendation relating to the
effective protection of the rights of unaccompanied children and their access to asylum
procedures. It noted with concern, however, that the principle of the benefit of doubt was
not applied in the assessment of a child’s age, and that migrants who arrived as children
were not placed in integration projects for at least two years and were not entitled to have
their residents permits renewed when adults. It called on Italy to introduce adequate legal
safeguards to protect the rights of unaccompanied children, and welcomed the acceptance
by Italy of recommendations relating to the improvement of asylum procedures and respect
for the principle of non-refoulement.
291. Rencontre afrique pour la défense des droits de l’homme noted that Italy faced great
difficulties in migration management. Some migrants lived in very difficult conditions,
working in some instances over 16 hours a day for very low wages, half of which they had
to give to the local mafia. It welcomed Italy’s contribution to the achievement of the
Millennium Development Goals in many developing countries, through the promotion of
food security and the right to safe drinking water. It encouraged Italy to establish a national
dialogue to re-examine recommendations that it had not accepted. Lastly, it requested that
Italy establish a favourable framework to rehabilitate victims of trafficking and to launch a
dialogue with the countries concerned to put an end to the distress of migrants.
292. Reporters without Borders stated that Italy seemed to be drifting away from
democratic standards with regard to press freedom, the financial status of the media and the
separation of powers. It expressed concern at a draft law that would criminalize the
publication of telephone recordings and prohibit publications relating to cases in which the
investigation was not terminated as well as the use of hidden microphones or cameras, thus
jeopardizing the freedom of the press and the investigative work of journalists. Reporters
without Borders further referred to a conflict of interest created by the control exercised by
the Prime Minister of Italy over public television channels and private media. In this
context, it expressed alarm at the restrictions on investigative journalism and political
92
GE.12-17781
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents