A/HRC/19/74
have a sense of involvement in and ownership of the undertaking. International cooperation
between different kinds of entities, such as international organizations and non-State actors,
involves different types of partnerships and is based on a recognition of their respective
areas of competence and responsibility. Cooperation should not detract from the neutrality
and impartiality of institutional mechanisms or of procedures for consultation with
independent experts.
36.
Cooperation also entails participation in a process. It is true that international
cooperation pays a role in emergencies, such as a humanitarian disaster or an influx of
refugees. More often, however, it is a longer-term process in which the parties work
together to implement a policy, an agreement, an action plan or a programme or, in any
event, to take action within a general framework with well-defined stages, objectives,
indicators and assessment criteria. In other words, cooperation is not an end in itself but a
means to an end. It is a way of mobilizing joint efforts with the aim of achieving an
objective. Transparency, accountability and periodic assessments, which are essential
features of this ongoing process, serve the purpose of measuring the results. Other
assessment methods include studies conducted by external bodies and periodic reports.
37.
Lastly, the idea of cooperation conveys some sense of a ―shared ideal‖. It is not just
a matter of relations of good neighbourliness, coexistence or reciprocity, but rather of a
willingness to look beyond mutual interests in order to advance the general interest. To
cooperate is not just to choose dialogue over confrontation; it is to act together in pursuit of
a common goal. The idea of international cooperation presupposes the existence of an
international community that transcends the relations between States. It is in this sphere that
the importance of international cooperation in the field of human rights becomes fully
apparent, in that cooperation becomes inseparable from the realization of the common ideal
set out in the Charter of the United Nations of 1945 and the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights of 1948. In the absence of an embryonic international community, it is
Member States that assume responsibility, jointly and severally, for guaranteeing the rights
so solemnly proclaimed in these instruments.
38.
It remains to be seen how these principles of legal argument, which are derived from
the notion of international cooperation itself, carry over into positive law. Article 56 of the
Charter calls on all Member States to pledge themselves ―to take joint and separate action
in co-operation with the Organization‖ for the achievement of the purposes set forth in the
preceding Article, particularly those of ensuring ―universal respect for, and observance of,
human rights and fundamental freedoms for all without distinction as to race, sex, language,
or religion‖ (Art. 55 (c)).
39.
Other specific obligations relating to other protagonists or other forms of
international cooperation have been established within this general framework. Cases in
point are the obligations assumed within other international organizations, particularly at
the regional level, or through networks that are established after bilateral friendship or
cooperation treaties are concluded. The strict definition of international cooperation and
related legal obligations should not be allowed to obscure a broader vision of the notion of
cooperation. As already indicated, cooperation cannot be reduced to a call for dialogue and
coexistence or to the contrast between mutual understanding and confrontation. The
establishment of dialogue can be a first step towards genuine cooperation, however.
B.
International cooperation in the field of human rights
40.
This is the first area to look to for best practices for enhancing international
cooperation, even if these practices do not necessarily encompass all the different elements
of the ideal model just described and even if their focus is generally limited to the overall
―effectiveness‖ of the system in place. The idea is not just to promote but also to ensure the
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents