A/HRC/40/60
46.
In April 2018, Indian investigative journalist Rana Ayyub was subjected to an online
hate campaign and death threats when she was misquoted on Twitter. 12 She was threatened
with sexual violence on social media and subjected to misogynistic vitriol and hate speech
for being a Muslim woman. A deepfake pornographic video manipulated to include her
face was circulated. She was doxed and bombarded with sexual messages. Her reports to
the police were not taken seriously, and the perpetrators have yet to be brought to justice.
Judicial harassment and criminalization
47.
The Special Rapporteur has received many reports of women defenders being
subjected to judicial harassment and criminalization. Women defenders whose activism is
interpreted as a challenge to religious customs have been charged with blasphemy; women
who work on sexual and reproductive rights have been charged with violating so-called
public morality laws. False accusations have been made against women defenders, for
example, stating that they are engaged in adultery and prostitution or in terrorist acts. They
have also been subjected to strategic lawsuits against public participation by businesses, to
intimidate and silence them.
Denial of participation, restrictions and reprisals for engagement with international
and regional human rights systems
48.
Women defenders have been excluded from engagement with multilateral
institutions, intergovernmental organizations and regional bodies on human rights issues;
some have been subjected to reprisals when they have engaged with them all the same.
States sometimes delegitimize their work, restricting or prohibiting their participation in
international meetings. NGOs have been excluded through the General Assembly’s noobjection procedure, which allows Member States to veto the participation of any NGO
without providing a reason. Gaining access to international meetings often poses
challenges, such as obtaining visas and funding for travel and even entry to buildings.
Women defenders have also reported experiencing sexism, misogyny and racism in
multilateral spaces.13
49.
A method of undermining women in civil society is the formation of governmentorganized “NGOs”, which then make representations in intergovernmental spaces.14 Such
organizations advocate for the support of government policies, enabling States to claim that
they cooperate with and support civil society groups while sidelining their critics. They also
create an impression of conflict and fragmentation in civil society.
50.
Women defenders have been subjected to travel bans, harassment, interrogation,
arbitrary detention and physical attacks before and after meetings. On 26 October 2017, for
example, five special procedure mandate holders expressed concern over allegations of
physical attacks, intimidation and harassment of the executive director of a coalition of
human rights defenders of Central Africa, Maximilienne Ngo Mbe, after she participated in
the review of Cameroon by the Human Rights Committee (A/HRC/39/41, annex I, para. 7).
51.
Of concern to the Special Rapporteur is the withdrawal by the African Commission
on Human and Peoples’ Rights of the observer status of the Coalition of African Lesbians
on 8 August 201815 on the basis of a 2015 decision by the African Union Executive Council
wherein the Council considered the Coalition to be an NGO attempting to impose values
contrary to African values.16 As civil society organizations have noted,17 this withdrawal of
12
13
14
15
16
17
10
UA IND 10/2018.
Submission prepared by the Sexual Rights Initiative, International Women’s Health Coalition,
Independent Consultant Cynthia Rothschild and Association for Women’s Rights in Development.
Available at
www.ohchr.org/Documents/AboutUs/CivilSociety/Procedures/CivilSociety/JointInputSIRI_%20IWH
C_CynthiaRothschild_AWRD.pdf.
Kvinna till Kvinna Foundation, Suffocating the Movement: Shrinking Space for Women’s Rights
(2018).
EX.CL./Dec.1015 (XXXIII), para. 8 (vii).
EX.CL./Dec.887 (XXVII), para. 7.
See http://independenceachpr.org/.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents