A/HRC/11/12
page 23
73. In addition, article 27 (3) (b) of TRIPS also allows members to exclude plants and animals
from patentability as long as some sui generis system of protection for plant varieties is put in
place. Some FTAs however, look to enhance patent protection for plants and animals, which can
have an impact on access to medicine.82
74. Some FTAs also restrict procedural flexibilities, such as prohibiting pre-grant opposition
procedures. Still others seek to limit the grounds on which compulsory licences can be issued.83
C. TRIPS-plus standards in the area of patent law in
free trade agreements (FTAs)
75. TRIPS-plus provisions in FTAs differ from agreement to agreement, but their purposes are
by and large to:
• Extend the patent term
• Introduce data exclusivity
• Introduce patent linkage with drug registration and approval
• Create new enforcement mechanisms for IPRs
1. Patent term extensions
76. TRIPS provides for a 20-year patent protection term, starting from the date of filing the
patent application. It should be noted that prior to TRIPS, developing countries only
allowed 5-10 year patent protection while developed countries allowed 15-17 years.84
77. Several FTAs require an extension of the patent term for pharmaceutical products under
certain circumstances.85 The extension of patent life in developing countries and LDCs can
significantly impact the ability of patients to access medicines, and may pose a burden for
national health budgets. For instance, it has been estimated that the three-year patent extension
82
Article 15.9 (2) United States-Morocco FTA.
83
United States-Singapore FTA, and draft United States-Thailand FTA.
84
See footnote 30 above, p. 114.
85
The United States-Jordan FTA, which requires a term extension for delays in marketing
approval but not for patent grant procedures, is an exception. However, most United States
negotiated FTAs require extension to “compensate the patent holder for unreasonable
curtailment of the effective patent term” due to delays in the marketing approval of the
medicines and the examination of the patent.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents