A/HRC/42/CRP.5
He also claimed the victims were with AA fighters.713 Another military spokesperson,
Brigadier General Zaw Min Tun, was quoted by the media as providing a similar
justification for the attack, saying six Rohingya were killed and others were injured because
they were “together with the AA”714 Some injured villagers later admitted to Buthidaung
Hospital received compensation from the Myanmar Army.715
311. The survivors of this incident had difficulties transporting injured people to
hospitals, as boat transport was the only means for moving the victims. 716 The ICRC in a
statement said that it had visited the wounded in hospital and that they were in “urgent need
of surgery”. They offered their support, in case of need, including medical supplies or
transfer to Sittwe hospital.717
312. The Mission did not receive any reports from witnesses who saw, or knew of the AA
being, in the immediate area at the time of the attack.718 The AA spokesperson Khine
Thukha denied that the AA was engaged in any fighting in the area on the day of the
helicopter attack.719 From photographs of the victims, reviewed by the Mission, the victims
all appeared to be in civilian clothing.
Conclusions and legal findings
313. The Mission concludes on reasonable grounds that the Tatmadaw’s helicopter attack
in the Sai Din (San Goe Taung) mountain area on 3 April 2019 constituted an
indiscriminate attack that killed and injured civilians, possibly as a result of the Tatmadaw
failing to do everything feasible to verify that the people it attacked were civilians. The
facts also provide strong indications that the attack may in fact have been directed at
Rohingya civilians. These are all violations of international humanitarian law.720 Making
civilians the object of attack is also a war crime. 721 The Mission draws this conclusion from
several observations. AA fighters regularly wear identifiable uniforms while operating
outside populated areas, whereas the people killed in the attacks wore civilian clothes. The
helicopter operators must have been able to observe this distinction when the helicopter
713
714
715
716
717
718
719
720
721
96
V-370, The Office of the Commander-in-Chief of Defence Services, "Tatmadaw fought the AA
violent insurgents that arrived near War Kaote Chaung village with the intention to intimidate nearby
villages in the vicinity, including Buthidaung Town and Wa Kaote Chaung village" (4 April 2019):
http://cincds.gov.mm/node/2371, Radio Free Asia, “Myanmar Military Acknowledges Deadly
Helicopter Attacks on Rohingya Villagers” (05 April 2019), Frontier Myanmar, “Myanmar says six
Rohingya killed in attack were 'with insurgents' (08 April 2019).
The Office of the Commander-in-Chief of Defence Services, "Tatmadaw fought the AA violent
insurgents that arrived near War Kaote Chaung village with the intention to intimidate nearby villages
in the vincinity, including Buthidaung Town and Wa Kaote Chaung village" (4 April 2019):
http://cincds.gov.mm/node/2371; The Irrawaddy, “Six Rohingya Workers Killed in Army Helicopter
Attack” (04 April 2019), UCANEWS, “Six Rohingya killed in Rakhine helicopter attack” Myanmar
military claims that Muslim villagers were with Arakan Army members in Buthidaung (05 April
2019), Radio Free Asia, “Myanmar Military Acknowledges Deadly Helicopter Attacks on Rohingya
Villagers” (05 April 2019).
V-370, http://cincds.gov.mm/node/2371 (Myawady Daily).
LM-058, V-370, Radio Free Asia, “Myanmar Army Helicopter Attack Kills at Least 10 Rohingya
Muslims in Rakhine State” (04 April 2019).
Reuters, “Myanmar villagers, lawmaker say 'helicopter attack' kills five Rohingya, wounds 13” (04
April 2019), U.S.News, “Myanmar Villagers, Lawmaker Say 'Helicopter Attack' Kills Five Rohingya,
Wounds 13” (04 April 2019), Dhaka Tribune, “Helicopter attack kills five Rohingyas, wounds
13” (04 April 2019), The Daily Star “Helicopter attack kills 5 Rohingyas” (05 April 2019), Press TV,
“Five killed as Myanmar military chopper attacks Rohingya Muslims” (04 April 2019).
FI-026, UCANEWS, “Six Rohingya killed in Rakhine helicopter attack” Myanmar military claims
that Muslim villagers were with Arakan Army members in Buthidaung (05 April 2019).
Radio Free Asia, “Myanmar Army Helicopter Attack Kills at Least 10 Rohingya Muslims in Rakhine
State” (04 April 2019), The Irrawaddy, “Six Rohingya Workers Killed in Army Helicopter Attack”
(04 April 2019).
See J.M. Henckaerts and L. Doswald-Beck, “Customary International Humanitarian Law. Volume I:
Rules” (Cambridge, ICRC/Cambridge University Press, 2005), rule 11 (indiscriminate attacks), rule
16 (target verification), and rule 1 (the principles of distinction between civilians and combatants).
Ibid, rule 156 (definition of war crimes).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents