A/HRC/23/22
have abolished or suspended conscription since 2009 include Albania, Ecuador, Poland and
Sweden, according to the International Fellowship of Reconciliation. Ukraine indicated that
it was presently transitioning to an all voluntary armed forces. Mauritius indicated that it
did not have a military force, but a Special Mobile Force, that was part of the police and
under the command of the Commissioner of Police.
41.
The German Institute for Human Rights indicated that, with the end of compulsory
military service in Germany, the programme for alternative service had also been
suspended. However, it was recognized that the alternative service programme had
significant benefits to German society, and that in 50 years, 2,718,360 young men had
engaged in useful service to 37,000 social and charitable organizations. Consequently,
Germany had established a new federal volunteer service open to men and women at all
ages to engage in voluntary activity on a broad social scale. It was hoped that the new
federal volunteer service would partially compensate those social and charitable institutions
which had benefited from alternative civilian service.
B.
Alternative service
42.
The Russian Federation indicated that article 59 of its Constitution recognized the
right to conscientious objection to military service and the right to alternative service. Its
submission stated that alternative service was regulated by the Federal Law on Alternative
Civilian Service and that, from 2009 to 2012, the number of persons undertaking alternative
service had steadily increased each year from 391 in 2009 to 587 in 2012.
43.
Alternative military service, according to the European Organisation of Military
Associations, should not be more than one and a half times the length of military service.
War Resisters International said that best practice in relation to alternative service was
exemplified by Denmark, which had alternative military service of the same length as
military service. Since 2011, Norway had suspended substitute service for conscientious
objectors.
44.
Ukraine reported that, under its alternative service programme, all worked
performed in a civilian capacity was regulated by the same labour laws and regulations
applicable to other employees. Georgia reported that citizens performing civilian alternative
service were usually assigned according to their place of residence and include participation
in: (a) rescue, ecological, fire-prevention activities; (b) engineering, repair organizations;
(c) organizations and facilities involving agricultural production; (d) establishments of
health protection; and (e) public service establishments.
45.
Greece reported that it had an alternative civilian service that was slightly longer
than military service and that the period of service varied according to the length of service
in the respective branches in the armed forces. The Ombudsman of Guatemala reported that
there was a national service requirement that could be fulfilled either in the military or in a
civilian capacity.
C.
Recognition of the right to conscientious objection to military service
for conscripts and those serving voluntarily
46.
The European Organisation of Military Associations indicated that conscientious
objection should be available to both conscripts and persons serving voluntarily in the
armed forces, both prior to and during military service. In replies to the request for
information for the present report, it was indicated that in Georgia and Serbia, persons
serving in the reserves can apply for conscientious objection to military service.
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents