A/HRC/5/11
Page 2
1.
On 6 July 2006 the Human Rights Council adopted resolution S-1/1 in which it decided
to “dispatch an urgent fact-finding mission [to the Occupied Palestinian Territory] headed by the
Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since
1967”. The resolution failed to provide details of the mandate. In particular, it failed to indicate
which facts were to be investigated. The preamble, however, suggests that the purpose was to
examine the humanitarian consequences of the Israel Defence Forces’ (IDF) “Operation Summer
Rains” in Gaza and the arrest of Palestinian legislators in the West Bank. Also, the resolution
contained no reporting obligation (unlike Human Rights Council resolution S-3/1, entitled
"Human rights violations emanating from Israeli military incursions in the Occupied Palestinian
Territory, including the recent one in northern Gaza and the assault on Beit Hanoun".)
2.
At the time that the resolution was being debated, I communicated with the proposers of
the resolution and suggested to them that someone other than myself be mandated to carry out
the mission, as it was unlikely that Israel would consent to such a mission under my direction in
the light of my critical reports on Israel’s policies and practices in the Occupied Palestinian
Territory (OPT). The proposers of the resolution did not heed my suggestion and instead
continued with their resolution, directing me to carry out the fact-finding mission.
3.
Unperturbed by the flaws in resolution S-1/1, and the likelihood that Israel would refuse
to consent to the mission, I went ahead and prepared for the mission, ably assisted by the staff of
OHCHR. For this purpose I constituted a mission comprising of myself, a health expert and a
security expert, together with interpreters and OHCHR staff. Details of these preparations are
contained in my report to the Human Rights Council of 20 December 2006 (see A/HRC/4/116,
entitled “Report of the Special Rapporteur on the human rights situation in the Palestinian
territories occupied since 1967 pursuant to resolution 3/1 of the Human Rights Council”).
4.
Under the terms of General Assembly resolution 46/59, no fact-finding mission may be
undertaken without the consent of the State to be investigated. The Government of Israel,
despite representations from the President of the Human Rights Council, failed to respond
positively to requests for the mission to take place, as I had predicted to the proposers of the
resolution. On 8 August 2006, I wrote to the President requesting him to inform the Human
Rights Council that Israel had failed to consent to the mission and that as far as I was concerned
the mission could not proceed (see A/HRC/4/116).
5.
From 1 to 8 December 2006 I visited Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory in my
capacity as Special Rapporteur. As on previous visits, the Government of Israel placed no
obstacles in the way of my visit and indeed on occasion facilitated my visit by issuing me a “To
Whom It May Concern” letter instructing Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) officers at crossings and
checkpoints to allow me free passage. However, as in the past, the Government of Israel refused
to meet with me, as it does not recognize my mandate. In writing to the Government of Israel
about my proposed visit in December, as a matter of courtesy, I assured the Government that I
intended visiting in my capacity as Special Rapporteur and not in my capacity as head of the
fact-finding mission mandated by resolution S-1/1. I am confident that without such an
assurance I would not have been permitted to enter Israel.
6.
During my December visit to the Occupied Palestinian Territory, I visited Gaza and
examined the consequences of both “Operation Summer Rains” and “Operation Autumn
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents