A/HRC/4/WG.2/TF/2
page 10
policy coherence in both African and OECD policies on MDGs. In his view, the Mutual Review
has added value, both in terms of substance and high-level political support it enjoys.
Furthermore, it can elaborate related processes in the context of the Cotonou Partnership
Agreement between the EU and ACP countries, the APRM and consultative processes.
40.
He further pointed out that there is no evidence of human rights mainstreaming, including
the right to development, in the Mutual Review, nor specific attention for the needs of the
vulnerable and marginalized. However, he saw some scope for recommendations to take human
rights concerns more explicitly into account and in this regard, partners could build on human
rights standard-setting achievements in Africa, as well as on efforts within OECD to advance
understanding on linkages between human rights and development. He concluded by saying that
the explicit recognition in the Monterrey Consensus of the International Conference on
Financing for Development of the importance of human rights, including the right to
development (para. 11), a document which in part inspired the creation of the Mutual Review,
could be an incentive to OECD countries to perceive the right to development less cautiously.
41.
During the discussion on the Mutual Review, the main issues raised related to the
question of how human rights, including the right to development could be meaningfully
included into the process. The following considerations were raised in relation to this question:
the need to move away from politicized and inaccurate perceptions of the right to development
and towards operationalization; the potential of moving forward in this regard in light of general
recognition of obligations for all parties involved in a partnership; and the need to “unpack the
elephant”, in the sense of elaborating more clearly the specific obligations arising from the right
to development and their implications for both donor and partner countries.
C. The Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness
42.
Prior to the presentation on the Paris Declaration, the WTO representative made a brief
statement, addressing current trade negotiations and aid related issues. He highlighted that the
interest of developing countries is at the basis of the Doha round of WTO trade talks, and that
trade and development are inextricably linked, as trade can play an important role in alleviating
poverty. He emphasized elements of convergence and gains stemming from the negotiations,
which are at the core of MDG 8, referring to measures for free market access, transparent and
simple application of rule of origins. He also underlined the stronger role being played by
African countries, as reflected in areas and activities under WTO. Reference was made to the
WTO dispute settlement mechanism, where complaints were increasingly being filed by least
developed countries (LDCs), and a commensurate increase in use of the WTO advisory centre’s
services.
43.
He referred to lack of resources and expertise in some countries, as shortcomings in the
trade negotiation process. Measures have, however, been taken by WTO members to provide
effective support and aid. In December 2006, the Director-General of WTO reported to member
States that resources (approximately US$ 35 to US$ 45 million) were to be allocated in coming
years. Three levels of monitoring of aid effectiveness were considered: tracking of provided
funding, monitoring of activities on the ground, and monitoring at national level.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents