A/HRC/42/24
B.
Participation and empowerment
55.
All experts agreed that participation and empowerment are critical to ensuring
accountability to women and girls affected by crisis. In this context, humanitarian
preparedness, response and transition should always emphasize informed consent, choice
and autonomy of women and girls in their sexual and reproductive health.
56.
Addressing paternalistic approaches in emergencies and ensuring informed women’s
and girls’ consent to and choice of the services they receive is key and requires further
unpacking. In many cases it is not always clear, especially in the absence of language
translation and awareness by providers of the local sociocultural context, that women and
girls in fact fully understand what it is that they are “agreeing” to. In practice, the power
imbalance leans towards the provider who makes the assessment of what the individual
patient needs. This is particularly acute when it comes to adolescents. Human rights treaty
bodies have explained that the onus of proving consent lies with the provider and must
never be placed on a patient. Third-party authorization requirements are another challenge
that was identified in this context.
57.
Working with communities and understanding their views and demands concerning
service provision was highlighted as an essential component of participation. This also
includes partnerships and supporting and empowering local women’s organizations and
rights defenders. Actors operating in humanitarian contexts often fail to notice and quantify
the human element; the spirit, cohesion and resilience of communities’ responses to
emergencies, including family and neighbourhood networks, which could be drawn on and
reinforced before, during and after crisis.
58.
Examples were shared where awareness of and demand and need for contraception
by affected populations drove provision, ensuring that contraception was provided at an
early stage beyond what was required in the Minimum Initial Service Package. Access to
contraception is a life-changing intervention, and it is needed throughout all stages of a
crisis. Examples were also shared of innovative initiatives which provided the space for
girls to be programme designers and implementers.
59.
Inclusive and participatory, multi-stakeholder approaches should be implemented
starting at the preparedness and planning stages, in particular along with communities and
first responders, to ensure that different stakeholders can participate meaningfully,
including in their own language, and are clear about everyone’s roles and responsibilities
when crisis hits. These initiatives should also be specifically targeted to population groups
that are most at risk of being left behind and disproportionately impacted by a crisis.
Human rights analysis can play a role in helping identify these populations groups,
including the reasons for their possible marginalization, and help devise effective, inclusive
responses.
60.
In the same vein, experts underlined that reaching all affected communities remains
a challenge, including due to insecurity, lack of infrastructure and remoteness. Reaching
women and girls can be particularly challenging as in practice, consultation with
communities frequently starts with a meeting of elders or traditional leaders, who are often
all men. Experts underlined the important impact of reaching and meaningfully engaging
also with women and girls in such communities, as emphasized by the technical guidance.
This not only ensures that services reflect their experiences and needs; it also empowers
them to understand and claim their sexual and reproductive health and rights. At the same
time, experts also noted the need to understand the risks in the local context, including how
humanitarian actors and activities could in fact do harm at the community and family level,
including by potentially putting women and girls in situations of vulnerability.
61.
In this context, working with men and boys, including male religious and
community leaders, was also considered a good practice. They can be the support
mechanism for women and girls seeking sexual and reproductive health services and play
important roles in helping overcome sociocultural obstacles to the provision of services
perceived as sensitive and addressing the stigma women, girls and providers may face.
11
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents