A/HRC/19/68
injuries. The nature of the injuries indicated an intention to kill; the level of violence
suggests a central policy of violent repression. These actions are in breach of international
human rights law as an arbitrary deprivation of life.
B.
Unlawful killings6
1.
Introduction
23.
In the second phase of its work, the Commission concentrated on the larger-scale
executions by Qadhafi forces, but was aware that many individual killings also occurred.
2.
Qadhafi forces
24.
On 6 June 2011, 18 detainees died in Al Khums of suffocation from being held by
Qadhafi forces in poorly ventilated metal containers in rising temperatures. Seventeen
people died inside the containers, while another subsequently died in hospital. The
Commission was able to corroborate much of the testimony of survivors through physical
evidence at the site. It also interviewed one of the guards present at the time.
25.
In Al Qalaa, a number of detainees were tortured at a boy scouts camp used by
Qadhafi forces as a military base and detention centre. Following the retreat of Qadhafi
forces in July 2011, footage reportedly taken with a soldier’s telephone showed bodies in a
mass grave behind the base. Witnesses, together with the local prosecutor, uncovered the
bodies of 34 men and boys, blindfolded and with their hands tied behind their back. Three
other bodies were lying nearby. The Commission interviewed witnesses who had
participated in the exhumation and identification of bodies, as well as with former detainees
at the camp who had been released prior to the executions. The Commission also visited the
site. Rifle cartridge cases remained at the scene, together with some skeletal remains.
26.
An informal detention centre was established in a warehouse adjacent to the base of
the 32nd Brigade in Yarmouk, Tripoli. According to testimony received, torture and illtreatment of detainees were routine practices there. On 23 August 2011, as Tripoli fell,
guards threw grenades into the warehouse and then began to fire through the door, killing
dozens. As the prisoners were packed tightly, however, some survived and managed to
escape. Two days later, the guards burned the bodies of those killed. Of the 157 detainees,
only 51 survivors were confirmed. The Commission interviewed survivors and two of the
guards, who admitted direct or indirect involvement. The testimony was broadly consistent
and corroborative. The Commission’s forensic pathologist identified skeletal remains inside
the warehouse. Other forensic evidence remaining at the site was considerable and closely
supported the testimony. Six detainees, including three medical doctors, were shot a day
earlier in a second warehouse, a few hundred metres away. Three of the six died.
27.
Gargur, in Tripoli, was the site of another unofficial detention centre. Locals referred
to the building as the former “green security building”. Witnesses and survivors told the
Commission that, on 23 August 2011, guards opened fire on the detainees. A total of 21
people were shot and killed.
28.
Further evidence of executions carried out by Qadhafi forces was found in Bab Al
Aziziyah. On 23 August 2011, a witness described how he had helped gather 15 bodies, all
men in civilian clothes and all handcuffed. The Commission interviewed two witnesses
who had reportedly seen three medical personnel taken from an ambulance and shot. The
6
See ibid., chap. III, sect. B.
7
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents