A/HRC/41/44/Add.2
income.9 The lack of sufficient social housing is also an issue for persons living in poverty,
especially for older persons and persons with disabilities.
85.
The situation of employment for migrants, ethnic minorities and persons with
disabilities was raised, as such persons may experience discrimination in employment and
hold low-level positions in the labour market. Many part-time workers, farmers and flexiworkers who are poorly paid and find themselves at risk of ending below the poverty line
are said to face similar challenges. Persons with poor literacy skills and those with a low
level of education are also at risk in a highly competitive and intensive labour market such
as that in the Netherlands.
86.
Finally, the Independent Expert found that many persons from migrant or ethnic
minority background are highly educated and skilled and would like to assist their country
of origin in providing assistance and development but are unable to do so.
VII. The Dutch Caribbean – visit to Bonaire
87.
In Bonaire, the Independent Expert was able to see first-hand the historical,
geographical, ethnic and cultural differences between this Caribbean island and the
European part of the Kingdom. He was also informed of the political changes that have
affected the inhabitants since the new constitutional arrangements of 2010 that ended the
Netherlands Antilles and made Bonaire a special municipality of the country of the
Netherlands. The country of the Netherlands now exercises direct authority from The
Hague, just as with any other city in the European part of the country.
88.
The Independent Expert was informed that there are significant poverty issues on the
island and that many people are struggling to make ends meet. 10 The cause of these
financial issues is often given as the change in currency from the Antilles guilder to the
United States dollar and the corresponding price increases, the new tax system in force after
10 October 2010 and a lack of awareness among ordinary residents of Bonaire about
income-related support measures. Vulnerable groups with a high risk of poverty include
older people living on the State Pension (AOV), those with a disability that prevents them
from working and single women with children.
89.
At the time of the visit, no standards had been set for the level of provision of
employment, income and social security, whereas this is the case in the European part of
the country. Many of the people who work earn only the minimum wage, which is often too
little to make ends meet. Since direct rule by the Netherlands was instituted, many people in
Bonaire have found that their financial situation has worsened. Similarly, the Netherlands
Government and the island municipality are facing challenges when it comes to improving
the effectiveness of the labour market and expanding opportunities for finding jobs among
local workers. The Independent Expert was also informed about the isolation of the island,
as there is no ferry service between Bonaire and the neighbouring islands of Curaçao and
Aruba so all travel has to be by air, at high prices. This can have an impact on the
enjoyment of the human rights of residents of the island, especially their economic and
social rights.
90.
Since the new constitutional arrangements the level of education has improved
substantially, although there remains an inadequate connection between education and the
labour market and no post-secondary education is available on the island, leading to a brain
drain of students to the European part of the Netherlands or the United States. Health care
in Bonaire has improved since the transition, partly because of the introduction of public
health insurance and investments in infrastructure, emergency transport, equipment and
medical personnel.
9
10
Netherlands Institute for Human Rights, Poverty, Social Exclusion and Human Rights: Human Rights
in the Netherlands: Annual Status Report 2016, pp. 8–12.
Ibid., pp. 48–52.
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents