A/HRC/7/6
page 12
approaches to estimating prevalence in diasporic communities.16 The World Health Organization
(WHO) multi-country study on intimate partner violence contains a series of questions
addressing forced, child and early marriage.
42. Prevalence rates for intimate partner violence are calculated from answering “yes” to any
one of a list of behaviours: to “count�� as a victim, therefore, one needs only to have been pushed,
for example, on a single occasion. While accuracy of measurement is important
methodologically, and headline figures have undoubtedly raised awareness, it is an open
question whether all single incidents should be understood as violence against women under the
definition of the Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women. Within the NGO
sector, domestic violence has long been understood as a “pattern of coercive control”. Some
studies have begun to recognize these complexities and use data analysis to explore more
complex patterns. An Irish study17 defined “severe domestic abuse” as a “pattern of physical,
emotional or sexual behaviour between partners in an intimate relationship that causes, or risks
causing, significant negative consequences”; minor incidents, in contrast, were defined as
isolated events with little or no impact. Applying these analyses not only reduced overall
prevalence findings but also the spurious finding that men are as likely to be victims of intimate
partner violence as women.
43. Specialist surveys that address multiple forms of violence against women ensure that the
continuum of violence can be traced with implications for protection, prevention and limiting
harm.
Methodological guidelines
44. Bearing in mind the caveats outlined above, it is nonetheless possible to identify consensus
positions on good practices in measuring violence against women. Normalization makes asking
“have you ever experienced violence/assault?” problematic. Therefore, the wording of questions
is something of an art in research. The number, format and content of questions limit or facilitate
disclosure. Single questions are less effective than multiple probes, and the most effective are
behaviourally specific lists which avoid using terms such as “rape”, “assault” or “violence”.
45. Surveys will produce more accurate and useful findings where the following standards are
observed:
• Multiple opportunities to disclose through behaviourally specific questions
• Inclusion of a range of forms of violence against women
16
See A Statistical Study to Estimate the Prevalence of Female Genital Mutilation in England
and Wales (www.forwarduk.org.uk/download/96).
17
Watson, D. & Parsons, S. (2005), Domestic Abuse of Women and Men in Ireland, National
Crime Council.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents