A/HRC/45/51
commit discrimination and provocation to cause social insecurity and chaos. The comments
received from the Government provide further technical and statistical information on media
in Cambodia.
21.
In July 2019, several special procedures joined an allegation letter concerning the
arrests and prosecutions of Kong Raiya and Soung Neakpaon. Both were arrested in
connection with activities commemorating the third anniversary of the July 2016 murder of
Kem Ley.14
22.
The alleged offence of Mr. Raiya under the Criminal Code of Cambodia was
provocation to commit offence (arts. 494 and 495) occasioned by promoting printed T-shirts
featuring writing and an image of Mr. Ley. The Government stated that the activity was
aimed at inciting social unrest and hatred. 15 Mr. Raiya was detained from July until
November, when he was released on bail, along with a number of other individuals who had
been detained over the preceding months. In June 2020, he was convicted and sentenced to
two years in prison.
23.
Mr. Neakpaon was seeking to commemorate the death of Mr. Ley at the location
where he had been fatally shot. According to the Government clarification, Mr. Neakpaon
was arrested when he stated that the authorities should look for the killer of Mr. Ley. As an
individual had already been convicted in relation to the murder, the Government explained
that his statement could mislead the public and erode confidence in the court decision,
thereby inciting social unrest.16
24.
The Government has publicly clarified its understanding of the situation and the
circumstances justifying invoking national laws to limit freedom of expression. 17 The
Government stated that political discourse and commenting on public affairs with insult,
incitement to commit a felony, call for rebellions against a democratically elected
government, and the purposeful or unintentional spreading of fake news and disinformation
do not equate to freedom of expression and legitimate speech. They can jeopardize the rule
of law, human rights and democracy at once and for all. 18 Certainly, as the Government notes,
freedom of expression can be limited to preserve public health and order. However, political
discourse and commenting on public affairs, even critically, is not in itself sufficient to
threaten public health or public order. Criticizing the Government and holding it to account
is integral to a democratic society. With no political opposition, the role of civil society and
the public to hold the Government to account is ever more crucial. Constructive criticism and
the positive joint creation of solutions to identified challenges is important.
25.
Great care is required with regard to online content regulation, as the Special
Rapporteur on the promotion and protection of the right to freedom of opinion and expression
has reiterated. 19 The wide range of laws, including criminal laws, which continue to be
invoked to limit freedom of expression should be reviewed, in particular when pretrial
detention continues to be used extensively, rather than in the exceptional circumstances noted
in the Criminal Code. In addition, when arresting people during the current pandemic, the
Government should be mindful of the guidance offered by the Working Group on Arbitrary
Detention in its Deliberation No. 11, on prevention of arbitrary deprivation of liberty in the
context of public health emergencies.20
26.
The Special Rapporteur is deeply concerned over the recent increase in cases of
harassment and criminalization of environmental and land activists. In April 2020, the
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
6
OHCHR, communication AL KHM 4/2016, dated 12 July 2016. Available at
http://spcommreports.ohchr.org.
Government of Cambodia, communication No. 2019/09/328, dated 13 September 2019, in response to
OHCHR communication KHM 4/2019. Available at http://spcommreports.ohchr.org.
Ibid.
Press release dated 3 June 2020 of the Permanent Mission of Cambodia in Geneva, as reproduced in
Fresh News Asia, “Cambodia Mission in Geneva: spread of fake news and disinformation not
equivalent to freedom of expression and legitimate speech”, 4 June 2020. See also the comments
received from the Government, pertaining to paras. 21–23.
Press release dated 3 June 2020 of the Permanent Mission of Cambodia in Geneva, para. 4.
A/HRC/38/35. For a summary, see www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/Expression/Factsheet_2.pdf.
www.ohchr.org/Documents/Issues/Detention/DeliberationNo11.pdf (para. 22).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents