A/HRC/35/31
not firmly institutionalized and adequately protected can easily be corrupted or co-opted by
interests other than those of applying the law in a fair and impartial manner.
3.
Independence of lawyers and the legal profession
46.
In the first report, the Special Rapporteur stated that he would be vigilant with
regard to the protection of the important role of lawyers and their respective bar
associations in upholding human rights and fundamental freedoms. In this context, he made
an important distinction between engagement in the protection of human rights which have
political connotations, and engagement in politics per se (see E/CN.4/1995/39, para. 72).
47.
The Special Rapporteur acknowledges the importance of the standards set out in the
Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers and the Guidelines on the Role of Prosecutors. He
will give special attention to this matter, and takes the opportunity to call on all bar
associations and lawyers’ organizations to adopt the same course of action. The Special
Rapporteur wishes to express his support for and endorsement of all the actions that can be
implemented to this end.
Safeguards for the protection of lawyers
48.
As far back as 1998, the Special Rapporteur had already noted a constant concern
that had been expressed about the increased number of complaints concerning
Governments’ identification of lawyers with their clients or their clients’ causes, especially
lawyers representing the accused in politically sensitive cases. Identifying lawyers with
their clients’ causes could be construed in many circumstances as intimidation and
harassment, against which Governments have an obligation to protect lawyers (see
E/CN.4/1998/39, para. 179).
49.
The Special Rapporteur later declared that he would also pay particular attention to
any attempt to suppress or restrict the independent operation of bar associations, as had
been expressed in previous reports (see E/CN.4/2004/60, para. 46).
50.
Previous mandate holders identified prerequisites and safeguards that are essential
for lawyers to freely and effectively discharge their professional functions (A/64/181);
looked in detail into the provision of legal aid (A/HRC/23/43 and Corr.1); and addressed
again the importance of protecting the independence of lawyers and the legal profession
(A/71/348). Besides looking into the fundamental role of lawyers in providing access to
justice and the right to have access to a lawyer, the Special Rapporteur also looked into the
necessary safeguards for the professional functions of lawyers and their security and
important aspects of the organization of the legal profession.
4.
Special circumstances giving rise to violations of the independence of judges and
lawyers and the proper administration of justice
Reasons of State and the protection of national security
51.
In the first report, the Special Rapporteur declared that restrictions to judicial
independence based on “reasons of State”, including national security, should be carefully
scrutinized and clear limits established. He noted the importance of avoiding the excessive
usage of the prerogatives conferred on governmental authorities (see E/CN.4/1995/39, para.
58). A subsequent mandate holder noted that he would continue paying attention to States
where laws allowed the executive to order the detention of persons suspected of conspiring
or intending to conspire against national security and to keep them detained without charge
or trial, sometimes in secret and even without access to any judicial remedy or to counsel
(see E/CN.4/2004/60, para. 55).
Counter-terrorism
52.
Several reports and jurisprudence from international human rights bodies have
underlined the problems that certain anti-terrorism measures may present for judicial
independence and the independence of the legal profession. The use of “faceless” judges,
secret witnesses and limitations on the presentation and use of evidence are examples of
measures that affect the independence of the judiciary, restrict the defendant’s right of due
9
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents