A/HRC/35/23/Add.2
D.
Observations on Tabulation (B)
27. It should be noted that the communications the Special Rapporteur sends to States on
the subject of the death penalty are followed-up upon on the basis of a desk-based review.
The Special Rapporteur expresses her continued gratitude to various civil society and
advocacy organizations that facilitate this follow up. Establishing, at the very least, whether
an individual has indeed been executed subsequent to a communication transmitted to the
Government provides a helpful reference to whether the sending of these urgent appeals is
effective in ensuring that States abide by international standards, prospectively, in their
application of the death penalty. According to available information, executions were
registered in 8 of the 14 countries addressed in Tabulation (B).
28. As indicated in the table below, the main alleged violations covered in the cases
transmitted to Governments during the reporting period were: fair trial concerns in judicial
procedures leading to the imposition of the death penalty (28); juvenile at time of offense
(14), extraction of confessions under torture/duress (11); the imposition of the death penalty
for crimes which do not meet the threshold of the “most serious crimes” (8); mandatory
imposition of the death penalty (3), and execution of a person with intellectual or
psychosocial disability (2).
Death penalty safeguards - Number of communications
by alleged violation
Fair trial concerns 28
Juvenile at time of offense 14
Extraction of confessions under
torture/duress 11
Not " most serious crimes" 8
Mandatory imposition of the
death penalty 3
Execution of a person with
intellectual or psychosocial
disability 2
29. The Special Rapporteur continuous to be alarmed at the number of cases in which the
death sentence was allegedly imposed following judicial procedures that fall short of
international standards of fair trial and due process, a necessary requirement for the lawful
imposition of this type of punishment. Twenty-eight out of the 31 communications
31
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents