A/HRC/45/14/Add.2
breaches of privacy, runs education programmes and examines proposed legislation and its
impact on people’s right to privacy.
20.
The Office of the Ombudsman is an independent body with the mandate to examine
complaints about administrative acts and decisions of central and local government
agencies. The Ombudsman also has jurisdiction to inspect health and disability places of
detention, including secure aged care facilities, as well as prisons, immigration detention
centres and court cells.
21.
The New Zealand Human Rights Commission was established in September 1978. It
is an independent national human rights institution with A status accreditation, with offices
in Wellington, Auckland and Christchurch. Its mandate includes the settlement of disputes
relating to unlawful discrimination, and human rights training and education.
IV. Independent Expert’s main findings
A.
Age discrimination
22.
Age discrimination is explicitly prohibited under the 1993 Human Rights Act, which
was significantly changed by the Human Rights Amendment Act 2001, including with
regard to government activity within the normative scope. Ageist rhetoric, portraying older
persons as a burden, nevertheless remains pervasive and contributes to negative attitudes
towards ageing and older persons. This demonstrates that normative action, which is an
important signal to society that age discrimination is not tolerated, is not sufficient to
overcome stereotypes based on age.
23.
Whereas discrimination in employment is listed in the Act among the unlawful
practices, including prior to employment and in advertising, age discrimination is common
in the workplace. Legislation prohibiting age discrimination is not sufficient to change
employers’ behaviour, but may lead to more subtle and covert ways of discriminating. 9
Older persons, in particular, experience discrimination when seeking employment and in
accessing training opportunities, and they lack equal employment opportunities, which
affects their length of time in work and their ability to save for retirement. 10 There are also
reports of older persons being denied access to mortgage loans on the basis of age, and of
discriminatory practices related to insurance for older persons. Moreover, certain
communities and ethnic groups, such as Māori and Pasifika peoples and refugees and
migrants, continue to face structural inequalities and discrimination, which are exacerbated
in old age.
24.
Older victims can submit complaints about age discrimination to the Human Rights
Commission. While the number of older workers making a complaint about age
discrimination remains steady at around 60 a year, it is believed to be widely
underreported. 11 Stereotypical expectations surrounding age and retirement may inhibit
older workers from challenging ageism. 12 Complaints are mostly resolved through informal
methods. If the dispute resolution process fails or is inappropriate, complainants may take
their case to the Human Rights Review Tribunal for adjudication. The Tribunal can order
relevant remedies for age discrimination.
9
10
11
12
6
Judith A. Davey, “Policy responses to workforce ageing – existing, potential and a report card for
New Zealand”, Labour, Employment and Work in New Zealand (2015).
New Zealand Human Rights Commission, Annual Report 2018/19, p. 19.
See http://superseniors.msd.govt.nz/finance-planning/paid-work/age-discrimination.html; and New
Zealand Human Rights Commission, “Submission on strategy for an ageing population”, submission
to the Office for Seniors, 2018.
Davey, “Policy responses to workforce ageing – existing, potential and a report card for New
Zealand”.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents