A/HRC/19/69
112. In its report, the League of Arab States referred to bombing of buildings, trains
carrying fuel, vehicles carrying diesel oil and explosions targeting the police, members of
the media and fuel pipelines. Without further disaggregating responsibility, the League
concluded that some of the attacks had been carried out by the FSA, and others by other
anti-Government armed groups.
113. The commission documented instances of gross human rights abuses committed by
members of various FSA groups.
114. In Homs, FSA members were found to have tortured and executed suspected
Shabbiha members in retaliation for abuses committed by Shabbiha or plain-clothed
security officials posing as them. In late January 2012, in Karm Al-Zeitun, FSA members
and others lynched a man suspected of working with the State security forces, and paraded
his body on a pick-up truck through the streets.
115. In late December 2011, FSA members in Bab Amr captured two suspected Shabbiha
members following an exchange of fire. The two men were beaten by the local population.
In this instance, FSA members pulled the men away from the angry mob and took them for
interrogation to an undisclosed location.
116. In November 2011, in Bab Amr, armed group members abducted a foreign media
worker and mistreated him for several hours before releasing him.
117. There were also reports of FSA members in Homs taking security agents, their
family members or foreign nationals of certain countries hostage to obtain the release of
people detained by State forces. The FSA leadership acknowledged in a written exchange
with the commission that FSA groups had indeed abducted foreign nationals, but described
those captured as foreign fighters.
118. Some armed civilians in Homs, including armed civilians belonging to the FSA,
sought to exact blood revenge for abuses by killing family members of security personnel
or Shabbiha. The FSA leadership in Homs and also the local coordination committee
denounced such collective reprisals and tried to contain them.
119. Credible reports indicated that members of FSA groups in other locations had
tortured or summarily executed captured members of the armed forces or security forces. In
mid-November 2011, members of the FSA near Talbiseh tortured a member of Military
Intelligence during an interrogation. The captured man was beaten, whipped with a cable
and threatened with a knife. In late November 2011, a FSA group from Rif Dimashq
captured, tortured and killed a member of the security forces.
120. The commission highlights the fact that FSA members, including local commanders
that have command responsibility, may incur criminal responsibility under international
law.
V. Conclusions and recommendations
121. The grave and ongoing human rights crisis in the Syrian Arab Republic is the
consequence of a combination of factors, including a State that has failed to respond
to the legitimate political, economic and social demands of its people and its position
in the highly complex geopolitics of the region.
122. The response of the security apparatus to what started as peaceful dissent soon
led to armed clashes. One year later, the Syrian Arab Republic is on the brink of an
internal armed conflict. Diverging agendas within a deeply divided international
community complicate the prospects for ending the violence.
21
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents