A/HRC/43/21
5.
A total of 131 Palestinians were killed (103 men, 5 women and 23 children) by Israeli
security forces during the reporting period throughout the Occupied Palestinian Territory.
The vast majority of the killings and injuries happened outside the context of hostilities, in
which circumstances the use of force is governed by international human rights law and
standards regulating the conduct of law enforcement officials.5 During the reporting period,
11 Israelis were killed by Palestinians, including 1 girl.
6.
Demonstrations known as the Great March of Return at the Israel-Gaza fence, which
commenced in March 2018, continued to take place almost every Friday throughout the
reporting period. Protests remained largely peaceful, although on many Fridays
demonstrators damaged and breached the fence, threw Molotov cocktails, homemade sound
grenades and explosive devices towards the Israeli security forces and launched incendiary
objects. In particular, 508 burning kites and incendiary balloons were launched by
demonstrators towards Israel, causing significant damage to agricultural land and forests. 6
The Israeli security forces responded with tear gas, rubber-coated bullets, water cannons,
skunk water and sound devices, as well as live ammunition. Thirty-nine Palestinians,
including 12 children and 1 woman, were killed by the Israeli security forces in that context,
while some 2,078 Palestinians were injured with live ammunition, including 577 children. 7
Many of those injured sustained permanent disabilities: 55 people, including 4 children and
1 woman, had limbs and/or fingers amputated, 6 were paralyzed and 10 partially lost their
vision. 8 Two Israeli soldiers were injured after an armed individual opened fire at them
towards the end of the demonstration on 3 May 2019, east of Al-Boureij.
7.
OHCHR monitored several cases related to the killing and injury of demonstrators at
the fence. In the large majority of cases, it found no indication that the demonstrators in
question would have presented an imminent threat to life or of serious injury. Under
international human rights law, the use of potentially lethal force, such as firearms, for law
enforcement purposes is an extreme measure that should be resorted to only when strictly
necessary in order to protect life or prevent a serious injury from an imminent threat. 9 Two
incidents are particularly illustrative. On 21 December 2018, a 40-year-old man suffering
from a physical disability resulting from poliomyelitis was shot dead with live ammunition
to his head while approximately 400–600m from the fence, east of Al-Boureij. Witnesses
reported that he was shot while walking around the bus parking area. On 8 February 2019, a
13-year-old boy was shot dead with live ammunition to his chest while standing and holding
hands with three of his friends approximately 300m from the fence, east of Khan Younis,
southern Gaza Strip.
8.
Paramedics assisting injured demonstrators and journalists covering the protests were
also subjected to live fire from the Israeli security forces. Thus, 110 paramedics and 62
journalists were injured by the security forces, tens of them with live ammunition and
shrapnel.10 On 2 August 2019, a journalist was injured with live ammunition to his left leg as
he was covering the demonstrations east of Al-Boureij. Witnesses reported that he was
wearing a vest visibly marked “press” and taking photographs 200–300m from the fence
when he was shot. On 27 September 2019, a 28-year-old female volunteer first responder,
visibly identifiable through a white coat, was shot and injured by the Israeli security forces
with live ammunition to her right hand and abdomen as she tried to assist injured
demonstrators approximately 100m from the fence, east of Rafah.
9.
Of particular concern is the number of children who continued to be exposed to
unacceptable levels of violence at the fence. Children accounted for around 31 per cent of
the fatalities and 28 per cent of those injured by live ammunition during the reporting
period.11 Little effort appears to have been made by the organizers of the demonstrations and
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
A/HRC/40/43, para. 14.
Figures provided by the Department of Safety and Security of the Secretariat.
Figures provided by the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs of the Secretariat.
Figures provided by the World Health Organization.
Human Rights Committee, general comment No. 36 (2018) on the right to life, para. 12.
Figures provided by Al Mezan Center for Human Rights.
Figures provided by OHCHR and the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs of the
Secretariat.
3
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents