A/HRC/25/57
fundamentally on the reform of food systems in rich countries. Such reform faces
significant obstacles, however. The various elements of the food systems have co-evolved
over the years, shaped by the productivist paradigm that has dominated the design of food
and agricultural policies for decades. The farming sector has become highly dependent on
agricultural subsidies that have favoured the production of commodities for the livestock or
food processing industry – corn, soybean and wheat, in particular – rather than food, and it
has come to rely on cheap fuel for its highly mechanized and input-intensive mode of
production, replacing farmers’ knowledge. Even without taking into account the subsidies
for the consumption of fossil fuels by agricultural producers, countries of the Organization
for Economic Cooperation and Development subsidized their farming sector to the amount
of $259 billion in 2012. This has encouraged the expansion of the food processing industry,
thanks to the availability of cheap inputs and the deployment of infrastructure – in the form
of silos and processing plants – that has been shaped by and for agro-industry. Large
agribusiness corporations have come to dominate increasingly globalized markets thanks to
their ability to achieve economies of scale and because of various network effects. In the
process, smaller-sized food producers have been marginalized because, although they can
be highly productive per hectare of land and highly resource-efficient if provided with
adequate support,33 they are less competitive under prevalent market conditions. The
dominant position of the larger agribusiness corporations is such that these actors have
acquired, in effect, a veto power in the political system. Finally, the habits of consumers
themselves have changed: in high-income countries, the consumption of highly processed,
high-energy (though nutrient-poor) foods has increased year on year, becoming an
accepted, unquestioned part of modern life.
34.
As noted above, these developments have come at a high ecological cost. Due to the
links between agriculture, diets and health, they also impose a considerable burden on
health-care systems. They have led, finally, to the depopulation of rural areas. Yet, because
these different components of the food systems shaped during the past half-century have
strengthened one another, they have become lock-ins, seemingly blocking any real
transformative possibilities.
V. The way forward
35.
Nevertheless, the Special Rapporteur believes that change can be achieved. Actions
should be launched at three levels to democratize food security policies, thus weakening
existing lock-ins and allowing these policies to shape the new model that he calls for. At the
local level, the key to transition is to rebuild local food systems, thus decentralizing food
systems and making them more flexible, but also creating links between the cities and their
rural hinterland, for the benefit both of local producers and of consumers. At the national
level, in addition to support for locally-led innovations, multisectoral strategies should be
deployed. Such strategies should trigger a process in which progress is made towards
supporting a reinvestment in local food production, focused in particular on small-scale
food producers in the countries where they represent a large proportion of the poor; towards
the diversification of the economy, to create opportunities for income-generating activities;
and towards the establishment of standing social protection schemes, to ensure that all
individuals have access to nutritious food at all times, even if they have access neither to
productive resources nor to employment. At the international level, greater coordination
should be achieved between actions launched at the multilateral, regional and national
33
14
C. Carletto, S. Savastano and A. Zezza, “Fact or artefact: The impact of measurement errors on the
farm size–productivity relationship”, Policy Research Working Paper 5908, World Bank (December
2011).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents