A/HRC/39/25
delivery based on human rights, and to increase the use of services by the poor, the socially
excluded and disadvantaged castes. Efforts had led to major improvements in healthseeking behaviour, as confirmed by quality indicators. Care delivery was focused on values,
behavioural change, training, protocols and monitoring. The approaches taken in this
initiative had been adopted in the local municipal health-care systems in 2016.
26.
During the discussion, participants considered how rights could be employed from
the perspective of (a) legal frameworks and institutions that support the delivery of care
through requirements enabling human rights input to health systems; and (b) accountability
through the use of quality care benchmarks demonstrating the user’s perspective. They
stressed that the issue of discrimination deserved greater attention, given that
discriminatory barriers to health care were a central challenge that led to adverse health
outcomes. They reiterated that the rights of health service providers should be addressed,
and not only the rights of patients, given that, in many cases, the conditions of health-care
workers amounted to a violation of human rights. “On the ground” mechanisms were
imperative; changes should be accompanied by corresponding protocols. Education and
training played a key role, also for health-care professionals on health-related laws. There
was in addition a need for a greater focus on care and education provided to women, to
ensure that mothers were empowered by relevant knowledge and information.
27.
While some participants advocated for the expanded use of randomized controlled
trials, others pointed out that they were costly and might not be an appropriate research
methodology to gather evidence on the human rights dimension; they proposed that such
funds could be used instead for alternative types of research, such as implementation
research, including how to better implement effective measures that already existed, and
how to develop additional tools and metrics to improve human rights-based approaches to
child mortality. The right to privacy starts from the very outset; there was evidence that
showed that the prognosis for newborns improved when the right to privacy was respected
in intensive care units for newborns.
B.
Monitoring, evaluation and data to strengthen accountability and
quality of care
28.
Dinesh Poudyal of the Namuna Integrated Development Council (Nepal) discussed
human rights in public health and social approaches for improving child health and
accountability. He explained that gender and social discrimination were barriers to
improving health in Nepal, exacerbated by lack of knowledge and information, poverty,
difficulty in gaining access to health care and a lack of local accountability. In a three-year
project encompassing caste-disadvantaged communities experiencing the highest rates of
child mortality, progress had been made by addressing the infrequent use of maternal,
newborn and child services by marginalized groups and negative gender norms and by
promoting the empowerment of pregnant women. Positive change had been eventually
made in the district health system, particularly by embedding local accountability systems
and emphasizing a rights-based approach to health care.
29.
Prasanta Tripathy of Ekjut India addressed the role of monitoring to strengthen
community-based newborn health strategies. His organization implemented participatory
learning and action through community mobilization and capacity-building workshops to
improve maternal and newborn health, in accordance with WHO recommendations. After
10 to 12 group meetings, women felt confident to take on society and government officials
in seeking support to improve outcomes. Although the change process had been difficult
owing to established, hierarchical ways of working within the health system, the evidence
gathered through a monitoring system reflected major reductions in mortality by the second
year of implementation. Looking at the data from the perspective of inequality,
participatory groups generated the greatest impact for the poorest, as they addressed social
determinants and were conducted in local dialects. They had found that neonatal mortality
could only be reduced if the poorest rural homes were reached by community health
workers. The impact of participatory learning and action interventions had been sustained
over time, even though the specific pathways to results had changed over time.
9
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents