A/HRC/33/59
PP8 – ask clarification on “agroecological approaches”, with the source where this is taken
from.
PP10 – we appreciate the spirit of this paragraph. Much in line with the comment made
about PP6; the issue is wider than specifically the risks for human rights defenders working
on land and natural resources issues. We would therefore prefer if the para could begin with
a general reference on the risks for human rights defenders in general before paying
specific attention to HR defenders working on land and natural resources issues.
PP15 – is an example of the comment we made earlier in the general statement on singling
out selective parts of the covenants; freedom of association applies to peasants, but so does
the whole International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and so do the other
instruments. Would it not make a lot more sense to state clearly that that is the case and
then focus specifically on those elements where more work on implementation is needed?
PP20 – obviously not in the position to agree on this PP yet.
Indonesia
Article 30
Paragraphs 2 and 3 of article 27 of the declaration should be merged as paragraph 2 cannot
stand alone and paragraph 3 includes qualifications. The first sentence of the merged
paragraphs would read “Peasants and other people working in rural areas have the right to
be protected against unlawful eviction from their home as well as against harassment and
other threats”.
Paragraph 2 of Article 27 should begin with the addition of: “Peasants and other people
working in rural areas have the right to be protected against unlawful eviction from
home and as well as against harassment and other threats.”
Preamble
PP10. Include a reference to the Declaration on the Right to Development
PP16. Include at the end “with respect to the territorial integrity of state”.
United States
PP2 & PP14. Please replace the term “food sovereignty” with “food security” PP3 – Please
provide clarification on the phrase “should be provided with the means…” PP7 – What is
meant by the term “tenure rights” in the context of an international document?
PP13. This implies that treaties to which many countries are not party represent the
minimum rights under international law. Only if a principle has attained the status of
customary international law (principle against torture) or is jus cogens (like genocide or war
crimes) can it bind states legally – if a state is not a party to a treaty that so provides.
FAO
Article 30
1.
The specialized agencies, funds and programmes of the United Nations system, and
other intergovernmental organizations shall contribute to the full realization of the
provisions of the present declaration, including through the mobilization, inter alia, of
development assistance and cooperation, strengthening collaboration on reporting on
42
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents