A/HRC/25/67
seam zones; checkpoints; zoning and planning restrictions; demolition of homes and forced
evictions (particularly of Bedouin communities in Area C); revocation of residency rights;
the designation of vast tracts of land in the West Bank as closed military zones or natural
reserves; and the expropriation of land for settler agriculture or industrial zones, may
irreversibly disrupt the contiguity of the West Bank, undermining a just and sustainable
two-State solution.23
24.
Peace Now, an Israeli NGO, called attention to “Bibi’s settlements boom” in 2013,
reporting that tenders had been published for 3,472 new units in settlements, and that plans
had been promoted for 8,943 new settlement units in the eight months since the Netanyahu
Government took office in March 2013.24 Despite a brief and limited 10-month moratorium
on settlement construction in 2010 during the last round of unsuccessful peace talks (which
also demonstrated the ability of Israel to halt settlement activity if desired), Israel issued
tenders for the construction of 5,302 housing units in the West Bank, including East
Jerusalem, during the period from March 2009 to January 2013.25
25.
The timing of announcements regarding settlement expansion has also been
provocative, with the two most recent announcements coinciding with the first and second
round of Palestinian prisoner releases by Israel in the context of the renewed peace
negotiations that began in August 2013. The passage of time under the status quo has not
been a neutral factor for Palestinians, as more “facts on the ground” are created daily,
strengthening the position of Israel in its preferred mode of power-based negotiations (as
opposed to negotiations based on rights and international law). Despite protestations over
settlement activity by the United Nations, and notably also by the United States of
America26 and the European Union, Israel continues to use State power and resources to
promote its defiant settlement policies. The Secretary-General has described Israel as
playing a leading role in the construction and expansion of settlements (A/68/513, para. 3).
26.
This latter factor is important to note if the removal of existing settlements were to
occur as part of a peace agreement. Approximately half of all settlements in the West Bank
can be classified by type as either “quality of life”, or a mixture of “quality of
life/ideological”, which tend to be inhabited by predominately secular or mixed settler
populations.27 Israel might be able to re-incentivize economic settlers, who were persuaded
to move to the West Bank settlements through various government benefits and incentives,
to re-settle to the west of the pre-1967 borders of Israel. However, it would have a more
difficult time removing the more religious settlers who live in approximately 70 settlements
across the West Bank, all the more so as population growth in the settlements
(approximately 2.8 per cent) continues to outstrip population growth in Israel.28 It also
remains to be seen whether an emergent settler unity precludes implementing a future peace
agreement based on inducing economic settlers to return to Israel. Certainly, it may be
anticipated that ideological settlers would do their best to prevent such a division and the
implementation of such an agreement.
23
24
25
26
27
28
A/HRC/25/38, A/HRC/25/40, A/68/502 and A/68/513.
See http://peacenow.org/Bibis%20Settlements%20Boom%20-%20March-November%202013%20%20FINAL.pdf.
See http://peacenow.org.il/eng/sites/default/files/summary-of-4-years-of-netanyahu-government.pdf.
See www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/1.556645; www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2013/
sgsm15427.doc.htm.
Among 136 West Bank settlements listed by Peace Now, 25 settlements fall under the type “quality
of life”, 35 under the type “quality of life/ideological”, 70 under the type “ideological” and six under
the type “ultra-orthodox” (see http://peacenow.org.il/ eng/content/settlements-and-outposts).
Palestinian Centre for Human Rights submission to Special Rapporteur, 22 November 2013.
9
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents