A/HRC/17/26
81.
There is a need for a holistic approach to both physical and ideological restrictions
as an issue in the human rights discourse around violence against women. Mainstream
human rights discourse has demonstrated its capacity to acknowledge as a human rights
violation the violence that flows from physical restrictions which are created and/or
maintained by the State, communities, families or individuals. The same cannot be said,
however, for the violence of ideological restrictions which may be deployed to justify
physical violence against women or to restrict women’s choices in ways that make
submission to violent acts necessary to access resources and to demonstrate community
membership. Ideological constraints help either to normalize the differential vulnerability
based on the violence inherent in the context, the personhood of the women involved, or
some combination of the two.
82.
In addition, a holistic approach may focus on the structural aspects of discriminatory
violence against identifiable subgroups of women, and its connection to structural and
institutional inequalities. In this regard, challenging patriarchal notions of gender relations,
male supremacy and female inferiority, whether justified by religion, culture or tradition as
a cross-cultural and international phenomenon, requires a holistic approach.
1.
The right to an adequate standard of living
83.
The right to adequate housing, food, water, sanitation and other elements of the right
to an adequate standard of living are firmly enshrined in international human rights law. A
host of institutional and structural obstacles prevent many women in the world from
enjoying these rights, thereby fostering inequality. Violations of such rights can exacerbate
violence against women, sometimes with deadly effects.
84.
Starvation in a world in which food is plentiful is a form of violence inflicted on the
body – both physically and mentally. Many studies recognize the discrimination inherent in
starvation, which affects the world’s women and girls at a disproportionately higher level
than men and boys. The human right to food still faces important challenges, as starvation
continues to exist throughout the world.
85.
In order to flee violent situations, women and girls must have the right to adequate
housing enforced. Adequate housing refers not only to sufficient housing options, but also
to secure ones. Lack of access to and availability of housing options for women seeking
security puts women’s lives at risk. Furthermore, housing in areas where violence is
rampant jeopardizes the lives of women and their families.
86.
The right to adequate housing is often particularly compromised for refugee women,
especially in conflict and post-conflict situations. Women are often left with no other option
but to take shelter in temporary camps where rape and other forms of violence are the norm.
In these cases, women experience multiple forms of violence – displacement from the
home, sub-standard temporary housing, and the high risk of experiencing physical and
sexual violence, without any available recourse. Thus in the case of refugee women there is
a failure to meet women’s basic needs on multiple fronts.
87.
The right to security and bodily integrity per se is essential for the enjoyment of
other human rights. All people, regardless of citizenship, gender, race, ethnicity, national
origin, and/or sexuality, have the right to bodily integrity within which health and the
environment play important roles.
88.
The current global reality of women reflects a failure to meet their rights in respect
of security and bodily integrity, across physical, mental and sexual contexts. Many regions
in the world are currently experiencing violence, both public and private – be it in actual
military conflict and combat zones, or in the aftermath of conflicts, or during periods of
supposed “peacetime”. Conflict and post-conflict situations often exacerbate an
environment of violence against women including through sexual violence, trafficking and
18
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents