A/HRC/34/38
40.
The application of two different legal systems in the same territory, on the sole basis
of nationality or origin, is inherently discriminatory. 86 It also violates the principle of
equality before the law, which is central to the right to a fair trial. 87 The application of
Israeli domestic law to settlers and of Israeli military law to Palestinians in the West Bank
also raises concerns regarding the obligation of the occupying power to respect the laws in
force in the territory it occupies, unless it is absolutely prevented from doing so. 88
B.
Obligations of all parties related to the conduct of hostilities
41.
Since 2007, there have been three major escalations in Gaza, which have resulted in
3,808 Palestinian fatalities, including 928 children. 89 During the most recent escalation of
hostilities, in July and August 2014, 1,460 civilians, including 556 children, were killed,
and 82 hospitals and 295 schools were either destroyed or damaged. In total, 90 Israelis,
including 11 civilians, were killed.90
42.
More than two years after the 2014 escalation of hostilities, serious concerns persist
concerning the lack of accountability by the Israeli and Palestinian authorities with regard
to alleged violations of international humanitarian law, including alleged war crimes, and
violations and abuses of international human rights law. No meaningful investigation has
been announced by the Palestinian authorities so far. 91 A high number of cases involving
the Israel Defense Forces will not be subject to criminal investigation as they were closed
by the Office of the Israeli Military Advocate General for lack of reasonable grounds for
suspicion of criminal behaviour, despite serious allegations. 92 When investigations are
opened, concerns remain as to whether they meet human rights standards, especially in
view of the small number and the low rank of alleged perpetrators that are eventually
brought to justice, facing mainly lenient indictments and sentences. 93 As for civil remedies,
victims have no prospect for compensation either. 94 This overall lack of accountability
contributes to fuelling the conflict.
C.
Further recurrent human rights violations in the Occupied Palestinian
Territory
Impunity as a driver of violations
43.
Despite various measures taken by Israel to address impunity, 95 the failure to ensure
accountability creates an environment of impunity where victims and families have little or
no redress, which may encourage further abuses on all sides.
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
10
assaulting a soldier. See Association for Civil Rights in Israel, One Rule, Two Legal Systems: Israel’s
Regime of Laws in the West Bank (November 2014) and B’Tselem, “Dual system of law”, 1 January
2011.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, art. 2.
Ibid., art. 14.
Convention respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land, art. 43, and Fourth Geneva
Convention, art. 64. The possible passage of a bill in the Knesset that would enable the retroactive
legalization of outposts built on Palestinian-owned land is of additional concern, as it would be the
first time that the Knesset enacts legislation to be specifically applied in the West Bank.
Figures from the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.
A Thai national was also killed.
The report of the Palestinian Independent National Committee established to follow up on the
recommendations addressed to the Palestinian Authority by the independent commission of inquiry
established pursuant to Human Rights Council resolution S-21/1 (see A/HRC/29/52) was reportedly
handed over to the Palestinian President on 8 January 2017.
Israel Defense Forces, “Decisions regarding exceptional incidents that occurred during Operation
Protective Edge”. See A/71/364, paras. 38-41.
See A/71/364, para. 40.
Ibid., paras. 56-57.
See CAT/C/ISR/5 and A/71/364, paras. 61-63.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents