A/HRC/4/74
page 10
V. OUTLOOK
37.
Impact assessments for private sector projects are currently discussed almost exclusively
for projects with large physical footprints, but in recent years industries such as technology and
finance have come under fire for not paying adequate attention to the human rights issues of their
operations. There do not appear to be any HRIAs for these industries in the public domain yet,
but hopefully this will change in the near future as there is no question that any industry can have
significant impacts on human rights, positive and negative. One of the case studies in the Rights
and Democracy HRIA pilot described in the previous section is in the technology sector.
38.
Similarly, the companies known to undertake HRIAs or comparable exercises are large
multinationals. As HRIAs for business become more common, both the costs and the benefits of
the exercise should become clearer, hopefully leading other business enterprises to experiment
with HRIAs. It should also become clear which approach would be most appropriate for which
sort of company, depending on the scale and nature of the business. A medium-sized enterprise
should not be expected to allocate the same amount of funding and staff time to an HRIA as a
multinational, but smaller companies could apply the same methodology with one expert rather
than a team, and place more emphasis on secondary research - although consultation with
affected communities is still critical.
39.
HRIAs are not currently required by any law, lending institution, or standard - most
certainly since they have yet to be clearly defined. But it should be reasonable to expect that
HRIAs will be undertaken for significant prospective investments in conflict zones or areas
where human rights abuses have been prevalent. When in doubt, a diagnostic tool or preliminary
HRIA (comprising secondary research and a few expert opinions rather than extensive
consultation) can determine whether a full HRIA is necessary.
40.
Given the proliferation of public information on human rights, including the numerous
specialized resources for business (e.g. the Maplecroft maps, the Business and Human Rights
Resource Centre, the aforementioned Danish Institute and HOM tools, and business-specific
research by Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch), there is no excuse for any
company, lender or investor to claim to be unaware that their investments could impact human
rights.16
16
See Maplecroft maps, http://maps.maplecroft.com; the Business and Human Rights Resource
Center, http://business-humanrights.org; Danish Institute op. cit.; Amnesty International and
IBLF, Business & Human Rights: A Geography of Corporate Risk, 2002,
http://iblf.org/resources/general.jsp?id=69.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents