A/HRC/19/57 Opinion No. 8 Country Government’s reply Person(s) concerned Opinion 34/2011 United Arab Emirates Yes Messrs. Abdelsalam Detention arbitrary, Abdallah Salim and Akbar category III. Omar 35/2011 Morocco Yes Mr. Mohamed Hassan Echerif el-Kettani Detention arbitrary, categories II and III. 36/2011 Mexico Yes Ms. Basilia Ucan Han Detention arbitrary, category III. Case filed (para. 17 (a) of the Working Group’s methods of work). 37/2011 Syrian Arab Republic No Mr. Abdul Rahman Detention arbitrary, categories II and III. 38/2011 Syrian Arab Republic No Ms. Tal al-Mallouhi Detention arbitrary, categories II and III. 39/2011 Syrian Arab Republic Yes Ms. Tuhama Mahmoud Ma’ruf Detention arbitrary, categories II and III. 40/2011 Bhutan Yes Mrs. Dechen Wangmo Case filed (paragraph 17 (c) of the Working Group’s methods of work – pending further information). 41/2011 Saudi Arabia No Mr. Ali Khassif Saïd al Qarni Detention arbitrary, categories I, II and III. 42/2011 Saudi Arabia No Mr. Thamer Ben Abdelkarim Alkhodr Detention arbitrary, categories I, II and III. 43/2011 Saudi Arabia No Mr. Mohamed b. Abdullah Detention arbitrary, b. Ali al-Abdulkareem categories I, II and III. 44/2011 Saudi Arabia No Mr. Muhammad Geloo Detention arbitrary, categories I, II and III. 45/2011 Saudi Arabia No Messrs. Chérif al Karoui and Hichem Matri Detention arbitrary, category III. 46/2011 Viet Nam No Mmes. Tran Thi Thuy and Detention arbitrary, Pham Ngoc Hoa; Messrs. categories II and III. Pham Van Thong; Duong Kim Khai; Cao Van Tinh; Nguyen Thanh Tam and Nguyen Chi Thanh 47/2011 Argentina Yes Mr. Carlos Federico Guardo Detention arbitrary, category III. 48/2011 Indonesia No Mr. Filep Jacob Semuel Karma Detention arbitrary, categories II and III.