A/HRC/36/55
eyes and impaired vision. Among the injured were 12 male farmers located 300 metres
away from the impact point, 2 of them minors. Nine medical personnel who treated patients
without protection also fell ill.
70.
While the Commission is unable to identify the exact agent to which the victims of
the 30 March incident were exposed, interviewees described certain symptoms, including a
very low pulse in one case, and contracted pupils, suffocation, nausea and spasms in
another, that indicate poisoning by a phosphor-organic chemical, such as a pesticide or a
nerve agent. The absence of a characteristic chlorine odour, coupled with secondary
intoxications among medical personnel treating victims, supports the conclusion that a toxic
chemical other than chlorine was employed. Given that Syrian and Russian forces were
conducting an aerial campaign in the area, the absence of indications that Russian forces
have ever used chemical weapons in the Syrian Arab Republic, 16 and the repeated use of
chemical weapons by the Syrian air force, there are reasonable grounds to conclude that the
Syrian air force used chemical weapons in Al-Latamneh on 30 March.
71.
As part of its offensive to fully besiege Barza, Tishreen and Qabun (see annex III,
para. 3), three rockets were launched on the afternoon of 29 March from government forces
positions into a residential area of central Qabun municipality, close to the Al-Hayat
hospital, as well as into neighbouring Tishreen. One of the rockets released a white cloud in
Qabun and witnesses recalled the spread of gas, which smelled strongly of domestic
chlorine. Thirty-five persons were injured, including one woman and two children. Victims
exhibited symptoms consistent with chlorine exposure, including respiratory difficulties,
coughing and runny noses. The most serious cases were treated with hydrocortisone l and
oxygen. On 7 April, shortly after midday, Al-Hayat hospital received two men suffering
from milder manifestations of the same symptoms. In the first week of July, government
forces used chlorine against Faylaq ar-Rahman fighters in Damascus on three occasions: on
1 July in Ayn Tarma, on 2 July in Zamalka and on 6 July in Jowbar. In total, 46 fighters
suffered from red eyes, hypoxia, rhinorrhoea, spastic cough and bronchial secretions.
72.
The gravest allegation of the use of chemical weapons by Syrian forces during the
reporting period was in Khan Shaykhun. In the early morning of 4 April, public reports
emerged that air strikes had released sarin in the town. Dozens of civilians were reported
killed and hundreds more injured. Russian and Syrian officials denied that Syrian forces
had used chemical weapons, explaining that air strikes conducted by Syrian forces at 11.30
a.m. that day had struck a terrorist chemical weapons depot.
73.
To establish the facts surrounding these allegations, the Commission sent a note
verbale on 7 April to the Permanent Representative of the Syrian Arab Republic to the
United Nations Office at Geneva and specialized institutions in Switzerland requesting
information from the Government. At the time of writing, no response has been received.
The Commission conducted 43 interviews with eyewitnesses, victims, first responders and
medical workers. It also collected satellite imagery, 17 photographs of bomb remnants, early
warning reports and videos of the area allegedly affected by the air strikes. The
Commission also took into account the findings of the Organisation for the Prohibition of
Chemical Weapons report on the results of its fact-finding mission.18 Below is a summary
of the Commission’s findings, elaborated in full in annex II.
74.
Interviewees and early warning reports indicate that a Sukhoi 22 (Su-22) aircraft
conducted four air strikes in Khan Shaykhun at around 6.45 a.m. Only Syrian forces operate
such aircraft. 19 The Commission identified three conventional bombs, likely OFAB-100120, and one chemical bomb. Eyewitnesses recalled that the latter bomb made less noise
16
17
18
19
See A/HRC/34/64, para. 17.
Satellite imagery analysis provided by the Operational Satellite Applications Programme. Available at
www.ohchr.org/EN/HRBodies/HRC/IICISyria/Pages/IndependentInternationalCommission.aspx.
Available at www.opcw.org/fileadmin/OPCW/Fact_Finding_Mission/s-1510-2017_e_.pdf.
See Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Syrian Arab Republic, “Human rights
abuses and international humanitarian law violations in the Syrian Arab Republic, 21 July 2016-28
February 2017”, para. 27.
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents