A/HRC/21/9
75.
Regarding questions from Austria and Ecuador on the use of secret evidence in
closed proceedings, the United Kingdom said that in a small number of cases highly
relevant national security evidence if heard in public would jeopardize the methods or
identities of its security services or those with whom it collaborates. It was trying to put in
place a system that enabled those cases to go to court in accordance with the rule of law.
76.
Regarding questions from Switzerland and Belarus about rendition and torture, the
United Kingdom said that it unreservedly condemned any practice of extraordinary
rendition to torture and it did not render people in breach of its legal obligations. Robust
processes were in place to deal with allegations of any form of mistreatment by United
Kingdom armed forces and appropriate action was taken when there was a case to answer.
77.
Responding to Angola’s question, the United Kingdom said that it wasn’t possible to
comment further about the case of Jimmy Mubenga whilst investigations were outstanding
but that his death was currently the subject of three investigations.
78.
In response to questions about the International Convention for the Protection of All
Persons against Enforced Disappearance (CPED), the United Kingdom said that it was keen
to move towards ratification but that it did not sign international treaties unless it knew it
could ratify them quickly. The undertaking would require considerable resource and
parliamentary time; as a minimum the United Kingdom would need to create a new
criminal offence.
79.
The United Kingdom said that it would ensure that the recommendation by the
United States regarding greater resources for the Historic Enquiries Team, were
communicated to the Devolved Administration in Northern Ireland.
80.
In regard to Chile’s question about the impact of the legal-aid reforms on vulnerable
groups, the United Kingdom said that reforms in England and Wales had been subject to
considerable amendments during the passage of the legislation in response to concerns
raised by NGOs and Parliament. Public funding for the most vulnerable groups had been
preserved but the impact would remain under review. The Scottish Government’s reforms
to legal aid were also designed to maintain access to justice as much as possible.
81.
Germany asked about the United Kingdom’s response to concerns regarding reports
on regular screening of personal data and house searches of Muslims solely because of their
religious affiliation, several seemingly overly broad and vaguely worded provisions in
counter-terrorism legislation, and the use of racial profiling in the exercise of the so-called
“stop and search” powers. Germany asked for information on how the interim results of the
European Union study on the effects that the imprisonment of a parent had on a child had
been assessed, and what steps were taken to improve support for children with parents in
prison. Germany asked what had been done to address the recommendation to introduce a
procedure for determining stateless claims. Germany stated that its strong recommendations
remained, making reference to the “Blue Group”. Germany made a recommendation.
82.
Greece wanted to know measures taken to alleviate the impact of the financial crisis
on women and measures to be undertaken to eliminate racial discrimination in policing.
Greece welcomed the establishment of a National Referral Mechanism for victims of
trafficking. Greece made recommendations.
83.
Guatemala congratulated the United Kingdom for its withdrawal of two reservations
to CRC and its ratification to the Optional Protocol to CRC on the sale of children and the
CRPD. Regarding the issue of discrimination, Guatemala asked what exceptions were
allowed by the 2010 Equality Act. Guatemala also wanted to know the main elements of
the Action Plan on Domestic Violence, since when it had been enforced, and what the
results were. Guatemala made a recommendation.
12
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents