Recommendations
A/HRC/33/51/Add.1
Situation during the visit
A/HRC/33/51/Add.1
Measures taken/current situation
Level of implementation and
observations (to be completed by
the WGEID)
crucial information on the disappearances. On the contrary, not
only the authorities were disregarding information furnished by
the families, but in one case they even warned that too many
postings on social media will harm the attempts to eventually find
the victims.
Eleven out of the fourteen family members currently outside
Turkey replied that they did not receive any protection against
possible reprisals, even though all of them received threats, in
particular through social media. In one case outside Turkey, the
victim stated that he was placed in a house arrest, in order to limit
the access of perpetrators. In another case outside Turkey, the
victim stated that he was provided a one-month security
protection by the government of a third country following his
enforced disappearance by intelligence officers. One family did
not answer this question.
LLG – TGRLSP
Measures have not been appropriately taken to ensure the
protection of relatives and witnesses throughout the proceedings.
For example, the trial of Ozgur Kaya was held on 24 October
2019 in a secret courtroom at the Ankara courthouse. Kaya’s
family were denied information from the court officials as to in
which courtroom his trial was being held. He told them he was
taking orders from the presiding judge.44
ICJ
44
Paragraph 35
No measures have been taken.
Ministry of Justice
The Working Group welcomes the
amendment to the Criminal Procedure
Code that allows reimbursements and
39
IPA News, Enforced disappearance victim being tried in “secret courtroom,” opposition MP claims, 25 October 2019. < https://ipa.news/2019/10/25/enforceddisappearance-victim-being-tried-in-secret-courtroom-opposition-mp-claims/> accessed 11 February 2020.
A/HRC/45/13/Add.4
85. Reconsider the practice of transferring
trials to geographically distant courts, in
order to maximize effectiveness, reduce
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents