A/HRC/45/16/Add.1
allegations of such pushbacks, including any acts of violence or ill-treatment that may have
occurred during such incidents, and to ensure that such practices do not occur in future.
88.
The Working Group was informed that the European Border and Coast Guard
Agency offered an anonymous complaints mechanism. While the Government indicates
that no complaints were made through this mechanism in 2019 for irregular pushbacks, the
Working Group considers that it may be a useful means of ensuring that any allegations of
pushbacks are received and investigated by the appropriate authorities.
7.
Legislative amendments and the announced policy on migration
89.
The Working Group notes the entry into force of Law No. 4636/2019 on 1 January
2020. The new provisions appear to introduce more restrictive procedures that may
compromise the general legal principle that detention of asylum seekers is exceptional and
should be resorted to only where provided for by law and where necessary to achieve a
legitimate purpose.
90.
According to article 46 of Law No. 4636/2019, persons applying for international
protection may be detained, if necessary, regardless of whether they apply for asylum while
in detention or not. In addition, as outlined above, the Asylum Service will no longer
provide a recommendation regarding the detention to the police.
91.
The Working Group also notes that the extension of the maximum detention period
for asylum seekers from 3 months to 18 months, which may reach 36 months if added to
immigration detention, appears to treat the detention of migrants and asylum seekers as the
rule and not the exception. The Working Group is concerned that these provisions are not in
accordance with the principles of proportionality, necessity and reasonableness, which
should govern measures of deprivation of liberty in the context of migration to ensure that
such detention is a measure of last resort.8
92.
The Working Group is aware of the Government’s plans to establish five new
centres on the islands of the northern Aegean at the sea borders with Turkey to create more
space to accommodate asylum seekers. It is unclear whether and to what extent these
centres will be closed centres, meaning that residents are in effect deprived of their liberty.
The Working Group received numerous allegations that the facilities, as created by the new
law and in accordance with the Government’s policy, will indeed be closed, as opposed to
de facto open centres such as the existing reception and identification centres. The
authorities have argued that the term “closed” means only that the entrance and exit of the
centre will be controlled.
93.
It is important to ensure that any new centres are open centres and do not reinforce
the practice of detaining asylum seekers. However, the plans also reportedly include the
creation of centres for unaccompanied minors staffed by doctors and psychologists, which
may be a positive development if they are not closed centres.
C.
Deprivation of liberty in the context of psychosocial disability and social
care
94.
The Working Group was informed that psychosocial disabilities are increasingly
common as a result of the economic crisis in recent years. The Ministry of Health is
prioritizing the deinstitutionalization of persons with psychosocial disabilities whenever
possible, which is commendable and has resulted in community-based care being made
available to more individuals. For example, Dromokaiteio Psychiatric Hospital in Attica
provides hospices, boarding houses and supported-living apartments to allow persons to
live independently in the community.
95.
With regard to the care institution for children and young adults with disabilities in
Lechaina, the Working Group encourages the Government to continue with the
deinstitutionalization process and to provide it with sufficient resources and personnel to
8
Revised deliberation No. 5, paras. 12–13.
15
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents