A/HRC/39/55
have clearly defined roles, responsibilities and performance standards; accountability of
such organizations is however weak and vague in the context of forced displacement.
58.
In the humanitarian-development nexus, unclear accountability mechanisms for both
humanitarian and development actors are contributing to unsustainable or discontinuous
interventions. The primary accountability mechanisms for both actors are centred on
accountability to donors, even though accountability to service users is increasingly
acknowledged as a shared goal in the water, sanitation and hygiene sector. 50 Both
humanitarian and development organizations have thus increasingly developed different
accountability mechanisms, such as feedback and complaints mechanisms (including
hotlines), despite the fact that there are no established standards on the extent to which they
would hold themselves accountable, the kinds of remedies provided, or the handling of
complaints received (including data protection). Human rights can offer an accountability
framework for organizations; in other words, a basis for defining what people can and
cannot claim and how to do it.
59.
When many actors are involved without any clear allocation of roles or
responsibilities, which is often the case in humanitarian situations, affected persons are
unable to claim remedies when their human rights are violated or not realized. The situation
in Haiti after the 2010 earthquake was an example of unclear accountability, where nongovernmental organizations running camps for internally displaced persons were able to
ensure better provision of water, sanitation and clinics in their operational areas, but neither
the Government, United Nations agencies or the International Organization for Migration
were able to persuade them to work in harder-hit areas. 51 In October 2010, substandard
access to safe water and sanitation contributed to an outbreak of cholera, which led to the
death of more than 9,000 people and the hospitalization of thousands more.52 The victims
have not had access to remedies either from the United Nations (which was responsible for
introducing cholera to the country owing to negligence) or from the State or other
organizations, which failed to provide the minimum standard of water and sanitation
services.
C.
Preparedness
60.
International humanitarian actors are usually required to address inadequacies in
water and sanitation services and the environmental sustainability issues that predate the
onset of a crisis, which then exacerbates these vulnerabilities. Strong human rights
protection prior to the onset of the crisis can, however, mitigate vulnerabilities during
emergencies and increase the effectiveness of humanitarian assistance. The effects of the
realization — or lack thereof — of human rights during times of stability are often repeated
or even exacerbated in humanitarian responses. Globally, water services tend to receive
more attention, funds and priority than sanitation owing to various reasons, including the
greater visibility of water projects, and the stigma and taboos attached to sanitation. As a
consequence, 2.3 billion people still do not have basic sanitation services and 4.5 billion
people do not have safely managed sanitation, while 892 million have no choice but to
defecate in the open,53 making access to basic sanitation one of the least achieved targets
under the Millennium Development Goals. Menstrual hygiene management is most behind
in terms of the development of standards and of a comprehensive approach, which would
comprise, inter alia, heeding the voices of adolescent girls, their privacy and dignity, and
tackling taboos and discrimination. The issue therefore faces challenges similar to those
faced by sanitation, but it complicated by the fact that it concerns a women’s intimate
50
51
52
53
16
Mason and Mosello, “Making humanitarian and development WASH work better together” (see
footnote 40).
Schuller and Levey, “Kabrit ki gen twòp mèt” (see footnote 29).
See A/HRC/31/79, chap. II, communication HTI 3/2014, and A/71/367; see also
A/HRC/29/34/Add.2.
WHO and UNICEF, Progress on drinking water, sanitation and hygiene: 2017 update and SDG
baselines, Geneva, 2017.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents