A/HRC/45/CRP.11
977. Ms. Granadillo fled Venezuela on 11 July 2018. She has not been able to continue her
medical studies and continues to suffer physical effects and psychological trauma from the
ordeal.
978. The Mission contacted the Government requesting a status update in this case on 7
August 2020. At the time of writing, it had not received a response.
Findings
979. Based on the facts above, the Mission has reasonable grounds to believe that Ariana
Granadillo, Argenis Granadillo, Sorbay Padilla, and at least five other relatives, were subject
arbitrary detention, to short term enforced disappearance and torture and cruel, inhuman or
degrading treatment. Additionally, the Mission has reasonable grounds to believe that sexual
violence was perpetrated against Ariana Granadillo and Argenis Granadillo in the forms of
sexual assault, threats to rape family members, and threats of genital mutilation, as part of
the torture perpetrated against them.
980. DGCIM officers under the leadership of an official with the alias “Captain Santiago”
were involved in the short term enforced disappearances and in the torture and cruel, inhuman
or degrading treatment of all individuals.
CASE 19: Karen Palacios (2019)
981. DGCIM occasionally arrested and detained civilians with no connections to military
operations or personnel and held them in DGCIM Boleíta. The Mission documented four
such cases, including the case of Karen Palacios.1712
982. Karen Palacios was a 25-year-old professional clarinettist at the time of her arrest.
Since childhood, she had studied with the national youth orchestra system. She suffered from
chronic depression and Asperger syndrome since her teenage years, dedicating herself
completely to her music.
983. On 26 May 2019, Ms. Palacios published a string of tweets that went viral in
Venezuela. She criticized the National Philharmonic Orchestra, alleging that her contract had
been cancelled due to her political views. She tweeted, “[…] Today, after the ninth
performance of ‘Popul Vuh’ they tell me that my contract was rejected because I signed
against the regime. Now I ask myself, when they called me to offer me the contract, why did
they not tell me that it was a prerequisite to think like them?” 1713 On 28 May 2019, Ms.
Palacios gave an interview on Radio Caracas on the programme “La Fuerza es la Unión”
with Jesús Torrealba to the same effect.1714
984. On 29 May 2019, pro-Government Twitter outlet “La Tabla” unearthed and published
screenshots of two (since deleted) messages Ms. Palacios had published on 1 May 2019 when
her account had less than 500 followers. Ms. Palacios had tweeted, “[…] I really hope to read
one sleepless night that Maduro fled, that he was killed, that he’s in jail, or any other crap
that could make me happy”.1715 She continued, “This crap will continue until the day we get
mad and 100 of us together kill 10 soldiers, or colectivos, or any other shit that dares cross
us”.1716 The two tweets had garnered no retweets at the time La Tabla had taken screenshots
of them. Following the publication of her deleted tweets, Twitter users began circulating
insults, threats and calls for her arrest.1717
1712
1713
1714
1715
1716
1717
192
Mission Interview C2EE18 in July 2018, Mission Interview C1AA027 in May 2020 and case of
Carlos Marron Colmenares.
https://twitter.com/KrenClarinet/status/1132718886615429121.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fRms5c0COc&feature=youtu.be
Screenshot of since deleted tweet available here:
https://twitter.com/latablablog/status/1133812775644553217/photo/1;
Screenshot of since deleted tweet available here:
https://twitter.com/latablablog/status/1133812775644553217/photo/2.
See, for example, https://twitter.com/luishenriquev/status/1133830772329259008;
https://twitter.com/mariaaliciaru12/status/1133868573280153600;
https://twitter.com/jos86rodriguez/status/1133846411219542016;
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents