A/HRC/45/CRP.11
examination was a routine check, not a forensic medical examination in line with the Istanbul
Protocol, and the torture marks had disappeared by then.1607
889. On 8 May 2019, the lawyers representing six of the sergeants filed a complaint with
the Public Prosecutor’s Office, along with a request to respect and guarantee the physical
integrity, the right to life and the right to health of the six men, in accordance with articles 43
and 83 of the Constitution.1608
890. On 11 February 2020, the lawyers brought the precautionary measures issued by the
Inter-American Commission in favour of Luis Lobo Medina and Andrés Paredes Soler the
attention of the first Military Tribunal. The measures related to their deteriorating health. 1609
The court took no action.
Detention in Ramo Verde
891. After the initial appearance hearing, Sergeant Bandres was held for a further two
weeks at DGCIM Boleíta and tortured again. On 4 February 2019, he was transferred to
Ramo Verde prison and his family was not informed. Having discovered his whereabouts,
on 8 February 2019, his family went to Ramo Verde to inquire about him. They were
informed that he was in an adaptation period and could not receive visits, during this time
Sergeant Bandres was placed in the “El Tigrito” cell for 15 days.1610
892. On 15 February 2019, Sergeant Bandres’wife and children were allowed to see him.
His wife told the Mission, “He was extremely thin; he had marks on his legs. His ribs were
purple. His arms and hands had cuts. He could hardly move them and he had scars and marks
on his face”. She said it was very shocking for her and her children.1611 On another occasion,
in April 2019, Sergeant Bandres was punished and left outdoors in the cold and under the
rain. He was later put in a dark solitary confinement cell, without a bed, and was not given
food. He spent around 15 days there, and suffered gastritis, dehydration and
malnourishment.1612 On another occasion on 24 August 2019 DGCIM officers stripped him
naked during a cell search, tried to choke him and beat him, breaking two of his ribs. 1613
893. On 28 and 30 August 2019, the families of Sergeants Luis Alexander Bandres,
Geomer Martínez Natera, Kelvin Manuel Charles Ramírez and the NGO Foro Penal,
representing Sergeant Andres Alfonso Paredes Soler, filed a complaint to the Public
Prosecutor’s office, on the treatment inflicted by DGCIM during the search in
RamoVerde.1614
894. The journalist Jesús Medina Ezaine was detained in the same annex as Sergeant
Bandres at Ramo Verde at the time. He told the Mission that the sergeants had arrived at
Ramo Verde with clear signs of torture and that he witnessed DGCIM officers regularly
undertaking cell searches during which Sergeants Bandres, Martínez and Camacaro were
badly beaten.1615
1607
1608
1609
1610
1611
1612
1613
1614
1615
180
The Mission did not have access to this filing due to limited mobility of legal counsel during the
Covid-19 restrictions, however, it is referenced by the legal team in the Mission Interview with Foro
Penal in June 2020; Mission Interview with Sandra Hernández on 24 June 2020.
The Mission did not have access to this filing due to limited mobility of legal counsel during the
Covid-19 restrictions; however, it is referenced by the legal team in the Mission Interview with Foro
Penal in June 2020.
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights, Resolution 5/2020 Precautionary Measures No. 75119.
Mission Interview with Sandra Hernández on 24 June 2020.
Ibid.
Ibid
Written statement made by Luis Bandres on 24 August 2019, during his detention in Ramo Verde
shared by Foro Penal on file with the Mission.
Information shared by the NGO Foro Penal of claim filed on 30 August 2019, to the Thirteenth Public
Prosecutor’s Office on Fundamental Rights and Mission Interview with Sandra Hernández on 24 June
2020.
Mission Interview with Jesus Medina Ezaine on 27 July 2020.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents