A/HRC/44/44
the territories of all too many small island developing States and, by extension, negatively
affecting human rights, including their dignity and self-determination. 116 Therefore, they
and other vulnerable developing countries invoke the need for international solidarity in
redressing the climate-induced harms that they disproportionately experience. 117
48.
This loss and damage agenda aims to rectify such global injustice and human
suffering to the degree possible, given the destruction emanating from climate change.
International finance, in particular, is a core means to achieve human rights-based
international solidarity on this issue. The international climate regime’s institutional
mechanism on loss and damage is examining some possibilities for extending financial
support in this direction (FCCC/PA/CMA/2019/L.7). Moreover, a human rights claim in
the Philippines may soon elucidate corporate duties to rectify loss and damage. 118 However,
progress on this agenda has not adequately reflected its importance. Loss and damage is a
“third pillar” of international law on climate change and should be granted the same level of
priority as mitigation and adaption.119 After all, States gave it an independent provision in
the Paris Agreement.120 The Independent Expert sees the unwillingness of some to develop
this agenda in the most robust way, notably through extending strong financial support, as
an acute gap in human rights-based international solidarity, demanding a substantive
enhancement thereto.
2.
Protecting indigenous peoples, local communities and workers against the negative
consequences of mitigation actions
49.
Ensuring access to justice for indigenous peoples and local communities affected by
climate change mitigation projects is yet another key gap in human rights-based
international solidarity. Not unlike international development projects, climate mitigation
may involve infrastructure and land use projects that displace local communities and
indigenous peoples, cause environmental damage and contravene rights to free, prior and
informed consent. For example, significant human rights risks are understood to arise from
hydroelectric dams and biofuel projects.121 The Clean Development Mechanism provided
few avenues to object to such projects and no rights of appeal or to compensation. 122 For its
part, the Paris Agreement acknowledges that parties should respect, promote and consider
human rights, the rights of indigenous peoples, and local communities, among others, in
taking actions to mitigate climate change. 123 However, States have continued to resist the
inclusion of human rights safeguards in the rules they are negotiating for projects that will
feed into carbon markets. 124 Setting aside other drawbacks of relying heavily on carbon
markets, the absence of procedural and substantive rights for groups affected by mitigation
measures clashes with the requirements of human rights-based international solidarity in
this area.
50.
On a different register, the international community has by now accepted that the
systemic ramifications of moving to sustainable economies will require international
solidarity to achieve a just transition that protects workers’ rights. In the present report, the
Independent Expert has also drawn attention to the reverberating effects that economic
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
In this regard, see the International Law Commission’s ongoing project on sea-level rise in relation to
international law (A/73/10, chap. X).
See Elisa Calliari, Swenja Surminski and Jaroslav Mysiak, “The politics of (and behind) the
UNFCCC’s Loss and Damage Mechanism”, in Mechler and others, Loss and Damage.
See www.ciel.org/news/groundbreaking-inquiry-in-philippines-links-carbon-majors-to-human-rightsimpacts-of-climate-change-calls-for-greater-accountability.
Julia Kreienkamp and Lisa Vanhala, “Climate change loss and damage: policy brief” (2017), pp. 2
and 7.
Paris Agreement, art. 8.
See the conference room paper by Tessa Khan, “Promoting rights-based climate finance for people
and planet”. Available at www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Development/Pages/19thSession.aspx.
See Sébastien Duyck, “The Paris Agreement and the protection of human rights in a changing
climate”, Yearbook of International Environmental Law, vol. 26 (2017).
Paris Agreement, eleventh preambular paragraph.
International Institute for Sustainable Development, Earth Negotiations Bulletin, vol. 12, No. 775
(2019), p. 16.
17
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents