A/HRC/27/23
8.
In Benin,3 Comoros (A/HRC/26/11, para. 10), Mongolia4 and Suriname,5 draft laws
to remove the death penalty from national laws are currently under consideration. Viet Nam
reported that it is drafting amendments to its Penal Code to reduce the number of crimes
punishable by death.
9.
In Sri Lanka, the Ministry of Justice appointed a special committee in October 2013
to review the Penal Code with a view to abolishing the death penalty. In June 2013, the
National Assembly of Tajikistan established a working group to study public opinion on the
death penalty. In China, the authorities passed a resolution affirming their intention to
progressively reduce the number of crimes punishable by death. As part of its reporting to
the Human Rights Council, China noted that it would continue its efforts in that regard in
accordance with its economic and social development (A/HRC/25/5/Add.1, para. 186.17).
Thailand reported that it intended to propose legislation to abolish the death penalty.6
10.
In many States, a constitutional reform process provided an opportunity for
discussions on the death penalty and led to proposals to abolish or restrict the use of the
death penalty. For example, in Zimbabwe, a new Constitution was adopted in 2013. It
provides for the death penalty only for murder committed in aggravating circumstances and
prohibits its imposition on women or on men who were under 21 or over 70 years at the
time of the commission of the crime. In Ghana, the Constitutional Review Implementation
Committee submitted a draft bill for the amendment of the 1992 Constitution, in which it
recommended replacing the death penalty with life imprisonment.7 Sierra Leone indicated
that the current review of its Constitution would present an opportunity for the examination
of the question of the death penalty.8
11.
In some States, the judiciary restricted the scope of the use of the death penalty. For
instance, the High Court of Botswana declared that the mandatory death penalty (sect. 203
of the Penal Code) was unconstitutional.9 In India, the Supreme Court issued a ruling
recognizing that poverty, socioeconomic or psychic compulsions and undeserved
adversities in life are some of the mitigating factors to be considered as a basis for
commuting a convict’s death sentence to life imprisonment.10 The Supreme Court of India
also adopted guidelines on clemency and the treatment of death row prisoners.11 In Uganda,
sentencing guidelines for courts of judicature were issued with the aim of strengthening
humane, predictable and consistent sentencing. The guidelines include special rules on
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
4
Statement of the Minister of Justice, Human Rights and Legislation of Benin, delivered at the Human
Rights Council on 5 March 2014.
Statement of the State Minister of Justice of Mongolia, delivered at the Human Rights Council on
5 March 2014.
Reported in April 2014 by the International Commission against the Death Penalty.
Information provided at a seminar on moving away from the death penalty in South-East Asia, jointly
organized in Bangkok in October 2013 by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for
Human Rights (OHCHR) and the Ministry of Justice of Thailand.
See Ghana, Constitution Review Commission, Report of the Constitution Review Commission: From
a political to a developmental constitution, executive summary and p. 644, para. 69 ( 2014). Available
from www.ghana.gov.gh/images/documents/crc_report.pdf.
Statement of the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Sierra Leone, delivered on 5 March 2014.
High Court of Botswana, State v. Rodney Masok, case No. CTHFT-000008-07, judgement delivered
by Justice Tshepo Motsagole on 2 October 2013.
Supreme Court of India, Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction, Sunil Damodar Gaikwad v. State of
Maharashtra, criminal appeal Nos. 165-166 of 2011, judgement issued on 10 September 2013.
Shatrughan Chauan and Anr v. Union of India and Ors, writ petition (criminal) No. 55 of 2013,
decided on 21 January 2014.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents