A/HRC/36/48
or banking services. Solutions based on information and communications technology can
also help create virtual communities and digital neighbourhood platforms for communitybuilding, and allow older persons to participate in online mutual support services and seek
advice.
72.
Participation begins with the direct involvement of older persons in the design and
development of assistive products and extends to the planning, delivery and evaluation of
services. It is also about ensuring their inclusion at all levels of decision-making. It is about
making older persons equal partners in the process, using genuine bottom-up approaches
(i.e. co-design or co-construction). Specific efforts must be made to include marginalized
groups and those not adequately covered in representative organizations of older persons,
such as indigenous people, migrants and refugees, ethnic, cultural or linguistic minorities,
and those with complex support needs.
73.
The use of robots and assistive devices may potentially lead to a reduction in the
amount of human contact. While during the introduction of new systems interaction with
health workers may increase, the use of robots for tasks such as lifting, carrying or even
cleaning might ultimately reduce an older person’s social contact with humans. Even if
interactions with robots, for instance social companion robots, could be potentially
beneficial for the physical and emotional well-being of older persons, the extent to which
they may replace reduced or missing interactions with humans, and any potential risks in
this regard, should be thoroughly assessed. 16
74.
Technology may perpetuate the view that older persons are inert and in need of
protection. Robotics and other types of technology should not prioritize certain forms of
participation, i.e. they should not merely seek to facilitate remote interaction from home,
and should not create distraction as a form of respite for caregivers. Some systems can
augment cognition. They allow the user to make choices and lead the interactions (for
example, the Computer Interactive Reminiscence and Conversation Aid). 17 They can be
tailored to the individual’s circumstances and preferences, and can also ensure the right of
the user to be left alone.18
7.
Adequate standard of living
75.
The right to an adequate standard of living requires, at a minimum, that everyone
should enjoy the necessary conditions of support they need. That involves the availability
of support services and assistive devices. Unless older persons have access to the support
they require, they will not be in a position to fully enjoy their human rights, such as the
right to an adequate standard of living. Such services and devices must not only be
generally available in the market, but they should comply with the principles of availability,
accessibility, acceptability and quality.
76.
Assistive technology must be available in sufficient quantity and accessible to all
older persons, without discrimination and especially for the most disadvantaged older
persons and those with high support needs. It should be tailored to the diverse spectrum of
the needs of the older population and be available within easy reach, based on individual
circumstances. Solutions that are only available in certain geographical areas, such as cities,
or that are only offered in specific settings, such as homes for older persons, do not comply
with the principle of accessibility.
16
17
18
14
E.g., PARO, a robot seal, which is used for therapeutic purposes, or MARIO robot, which is used in
dementia care for memory recall and cognitive skills and can verbally interact with patients via voiceactivated software; see also, e.g., Shuzhi Sam Ge and others, eds., Social Robotics: Second
International Conference on Social Robotics, ICSR 2010, Singapore, November 23-24, 2010.
Proceedings (Berlin/Heidelberg, Springer, 2010).
Astell, “Technology and personhood in dementia care”.
Tomoko Saito and others, “Relationship between interaction with the mental commit robot and
change of stress reaction of the elderly”, paper presented at the International Symposium on
Computational Intelligence in Robotics and Automation of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics
Engineers, 16-20 July 2003, Kobe, Japan.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents