A/HRC/13/30
49.
Up to the adoption of this report, the Working Group had received 31 replies from
the Governments of Belarus, Colombia, Ecuador, Egypt, Finland, Germany, Greece,
Hungary, Iraq, Jamaica, Japan, Kazakhstan, Lebanon, Mauritius, Mexico, Montenegro,
Oman, Norway, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Republic of Moldova, Romania, Spain,
Switzerland, Togo, Turkey, Turkmenistan, Ukraine, United States of America and
Uzbekistan. The Working Group is grateful to these States for their cooperation. To obtain
the broadest possible views and most comprehensive information, it decided during its
fifty-sixth session to postpone consideration of this matter until 2010 and requests those
States which have not yet responded to submit a response.
Video and audio surveillance
50.
In its previous annual report, the Working Group requested “States and other
stakeholders to provide the Group with information and share their experiences regarding
the installation of video and/or audio (recording) equipment in rooms where interrogations
related to criminal investigations are conducted”.18 It renews its call upon States and other
stakeholders to provide the Working Group with relevant information.
Alternatives to detention
51.
During its fifty-sixth session, the Working Group decided to focus on the issue of
alternatives to detention, both in criminal law and in the administrative detention context, as
one of its main priorities in 2010. It requests States and other stakeholders to provide it with
information, including good practices that it could recommend to States to follow.
Extension of mandate to cover all human rights of detained and imprisoned persons
52.
In its previous annual report, the Working Group proposed to the Human Rights
Council “to expand [its] mandate … so as to include the monitoring of State compliance
with their obligations concerning all human rights of detained and imprisoned persons”.19
For the reasons outlined in that report,20 and also in chapter II, section A, of this report, it
reiterates its proposal.
Revision of methods of work
53.
To further enhance cooperation with States, the Working Group, during its fiftysixth session, decided to focus on a revision of its revised methods of work,21 both in terms
of procedure and substance, and to share with Member States its newly revised methods of
work.
III. Thematic considerations
A.
Detention of immigrants in an irregular situation
54.
In resolution 1997/50 the Commission on Human Rights clarified and extended the
mandate of the Working Group to cover the issue of administrative custody of asylumseekers and immigrants. It has therefore since then devoted particular attention to the
situation of detained migrants, identified challenges and best practices, explored ways to
18
19
20
21
16
A/HRC/10/21, para. 83.
Ibid., para. 78.
Ibid., paras. 42 ff.
E/CN.4/1998/44, annex I, p. 15.
GE.10-10294
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents