A/HRC/41/CRP.2
people’s republic’ and ‘Luhansk people’s republic’ have yet to secure the full resumption of
OHCHR operations in the territory they control.16
II. OHCHR methodology
19.
This report is based on 179 in-depth interviews with individuals, including victims
and witnesses of human rights violations and abuses. Information is generally obtained from
victims, witnesses, relatives of victims and lawyers, site visits, Government representatives,
civil society and other interlocutors, trial monitoring, as well as court documents, officials
records, open-source and other relevant material. Findings are based on verified information
collected from primary and secondary sources that are assessed as credible and reliable.
Findings are included in the report where the “reasonable grounds” standard of proof is met,
namely where, based on a body of verified information, an ordinarily prudent observer would
have reasonable grounds to believe that the facts took place as described and, where legal
conclusions are drawn, that these facts meet all the elements of a violation.
20.
OHCHR applies the same due diligence and standard of proof when documenting
conflict-related civilian casualties. OHCHR documents such casualties by consulting a broad
range of sources and types of information that are evaluated based on credibility and
reliability: victims and their relatives; witnesses; official records; open-source documents,
photo and video materials; forensic records and reports; criminal investigation materials;
court documents; public reports of the OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine; reports
by international and national non-Governmental organizations; public reports by law
enforcement and military actors; data from medical facilities and local authorities; and other
relevant and reliable materials. In some instances, documenting occurrences may take weeks
or months before conclusions can be drawn, meaning that numbers on civilian casualties may
be revised as more information becomes available. OHCHR attributes a civilian casualty to
a particular party based on the geographic location where it occurred, the direction of fire,
and the overall context surrounding the incident.
21.
Consent is sought from sources on the use of information, ensuring confidentiality as
appropriate, including an assessment of the risk of reprisals, in respect of OHCHR’s ‘do no
harm’ principle.
22.
While OHCHR cannot provide an exhaustive account of all human rights violations
committed throughout Ukraine, it is able to obtain and verify information through a range of
means according to its methodology, and bases its conclusions of patterns of human rights
violations, abuses and harm on verified individual cases.
16
With the exception of field visits to document civilian casualties and conflict-related damage to
civilian property in territory controlled by ‘Donetsk people’s republic’ which resumed during the
reporting period.
7
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents