A/HRC/4/28
page 12
health cannot be realized without health professionals. Equally, the classic, traditional objectives
of the various health professions can benefit from the new, dynamic discipline of human rights.
Human rights can help to reinforce existing, good health programmes, and they can sometimes
help to identify new, equitable health policies. They can help to ensure that health policies and
programmes are equitable, effective, evidence-based, robust, participatory, inclusive and
meaningful to those living in poverty. The supportive role of human rights extends to the
provision of medical care, as well as public health. Also, provided it is done in an appropriate
manner, framing a pressing health concern as a human rights issue can enhance its legitimacy
and importance. In other words, health professionals can use human rights to help them achieve
their professional objectives.
42.
Health professionals run the key international health organizations, as well as ministries
of health across the globe. Naturally, they dominate the health sector, both public and private.
Clearly, there is no possibility of putting the right to health - and other health-related rights - into
practice without large numbers of well-positioned health professionals understanding and
supporting this endeavour. In short, there is no chance of operationalizing the right to health
without the active engagement of many health professionals.
43.
Here, however, is a very major problem. To be blunt, most health professionals whom
the Special Rapporteur meets have not even heard of the right to health. If they have heard of it,
they usually have no idea what it means, either conceptually or operationally. If they have heard
of it, they are likely to be worried that it is something that will get them into trouble. The
problem is partly one of language: while health and human rights have much in common, the
language used is often different. That is one of the reasons why the Special Rapporteur is
presently completing a short paper on the complementary relationship between equity (a term
familiar to many health professionals) and human rights.
44.
Earlier in this section, the Special Rapporteur argues that some health professionals have
recently begun to take human rights, including the right to health, more seriously. This is
undoubtedly true and very encouraging. However, if further progress is to be made towards the
operationalization of the right to health, many more health professionals must begin to appreciate
the human rights dimensions of their work. The message must be conveyed much more clearly
and widely that the right to health, and other health-related rights, are allies and assets for health
professionals to use. Health professionals can use health-related rights to help them devise more
equitable policies and programmes; to place important health issues higher up national and
international agendas; to secure better coordination across health-related sectors; to raise more
funds from the Treasury; to leverage more funds from developed countries to developing
countries; in some countries, to improve the terms and conditions of those working in the health
sector; and so on. It is crucial that many more health professionals come to appreciate that the
right to the highest attainable standard of health is not just a rhetorical device, but also a tool that
can save lives and reduce suffering, especially among the most disadvantaged.
45.
Listening to those health professionals who disregard the potential of human rights to
assist their work, it sometimes becomes clear that they do not understand some elementary
features of the right to the highest attainable standard of health. Some do not appreciate that the
right to health is subject to progressive realization (of course a State is not expected to realize the
right immediately). Others do not grasp that the right to health is subject to resource availability
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents