A/HRC/41/43/Add.2
Solai dam breach
32.
The dam breach disaster in Solai demonstrates the need for more comprehensive
environmental impact assessment and a stronger oversight mechanism. In May 2018, a dam
used for irrigation of the Patel coffee plantation burst and flooded a village, causing the
death of at least 48 persons and displacing over 5,000.34 Investigations by the Office of the
Director of Public Prosecutions revealed that the dam had been constructed by unqualified
staff, that the dam’s water was extracted by the owner, that the water permit had been
irregularly issued and that the owner and Government had failed to ensure environmental
compliance. On that basis, the Director of Public Prosecutions ordered the arrest of the
farm’s managing director and general manager on criminal charges, as well as of officials
of the Water Resources Management Authority and the National Environment Management
Authority on charges of manslaughter, neglect of official duty for the public authorities and
failure to prepare an environmental impact assessment report. 35
33.
During its visit in situ, the Working Group met with members of affected
communities and was concerned to hear that during a meeting convened by some company
managers with the presence of local authorities, cheques had been handed to people who
had lost family members, housing and/or business, in exchange for their signing an
indemnity form that would absolve the company of any responsibility for the disaster. This
could amount to an obstruction of access to an effective remedy for victims.
34.
A Senate ad hoc committee was set up to probe the Solai dam disaster. This
committee formulated 27 recommendations, including requesting the punishment of the
charged persons and requesting the enterprise to cede part of its farmland for the purposes
of resettling affected families.
C.
Labour conditions
35.
The Working Group heard that the main normative frameworks regarding labour and
employment, dating from 2007, needed to be reframed to align them with more recent
norms.36 The Working Group was concerned to learn about precarious labour conditions
prevailing in the country. The Working Group also heard that these conditions were
exacerbated in special economic zones where compliance with labour and environmental
norms appeared to be weak.
Minimum wage
36.
The increase of the minimum wage in 2017 is a positive measure, but it remains
insufficient to ensure decent living conditions and eradicate poverty. 37 Moreover, setting the
minimum wage of agricultural workers at half that of general labourers exacerbates the
inequalities among workers and regions. 38 In addition, business enterprises, civil society
and workers underlined to the Working Group that this minimum wage was hardly ever met,
including in the supply chain of the public sector.
Labour inspections
37.
The Ministry of Labour and Social Protection has under its mandate a dual system of
inspection: general labour inspection, under the Labour Department, and occupational
34
35
36
37
38
Kenya, Office of the President, “President Kenyatta leads nation in mourning Solai Dam tragedy
victims”, 16 May 2018.
Kenya, Director of Public Prosecutions, press statement on the Milmet (Solai) dam disaster, 4 July
2018,
Employment Act, No. 11 of 2007; Labour Institutions Act, No. 12 of 2007; Labour Relations Act, No.
14 of 2007; Occupational Safety and Health Act, No. 15 of 2007; and Work Injury Benefits, Act No.
13 of 2007.
Regulation of Wages (General) (Amendment) Order, 2017.
The minimum wage is 6,415.55 Kenya shillings per month for unskilled workers employed under the
agricultural industry category, and 12,926 Kenya shillings per month for general labourers under the
general category.
9
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents